Low-frequency variability in massive stars: Core generation or surface phenomenon?

Abstract

Bowman et al. (2019) reported low-frequency photometric variability in 164 O- and B-type stars observed with K2 and TESS. They interpret these motions as internal gravity waves, which could be excited stochastically by convection in the cores of these stars. The detection of internal gravity waves in massive stars would help distinguish between massive stars with convective or radiative cores, determine core size, and would provide important constraints on massive star structure and evolution. In this work, we study the observational signature of internal gravity waves generated by core convection. We calculate the \textit{wave transfer function}, which links the internal gravity wave amplitude at the base of the radiative zone to the surface luminosity variation. This transfer function varies by many orders of magnitude for frequencies $\lesssim 1{\mathrm{d}}^{-1}$, and has regularly-spaced peaks near $1{\mathrm{d}}^{-1}$ due to standing modes. This is inconsistent with the observed spectra which have smooth ``red noise'' profiles, without the predicted regularly-spaced peaks. The wave transfer function is only meaningful if the waves stay predominately linear. We next show that this is the case: low frequency traveling waves do not break unless their luminosity exceeds the radiative luminosity of the star; and, the observed luminosity fluctuations at high frequencies are so small that standing modes would be stable to nonlinear instability. These simple calculations suggest that the observed low-frequency photometric variability in massive stars is not due to internal gravity waves generated in the core of these stars. We finish with a discussion of (sub)surface convection, which produces low-frequency variability in low-mass stars, very similar to that observed in Bowman et al. (2019) in higher mass stars.

Accepted to ApJL. Supplementary information available at: http://www.princeton.edu/~lecoanet/data/SupplementaryInfo_Lecoanet2019.pdf

References in corpus (40)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• Wave-Driven Mass Loss in the Last Year of Stellar Evolution: Setting the Stage for the Most Luminous Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Sub-surface convection zones in hot massive stars and their observable consequences
• Angular Momentum Transport in Stellar Interiors
• Internal Gravity Waves in Massive Stars: Angular Momentum Transport
• Rotation periods of 12 000 main-sequence Kepler stars: Dependence on stellar spectral type and comparison with v sin i observations
• How stellar feedback simultaneously regulates star formation and drives outflows
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey XII. Rotational velocities of the single O-type stars
• Angular momentum transport by heat-driven g-modes in slowly pulsating B stars
• Low-frequency gravity waves in blue supergiants revealed by high-precision space photometry
• Amplitude modulation in $\delta$ Sct stars: statistics from an ensemble study of Kepler targets
• Signatures of internal rotation discovered in the Kepler data of five slowly pulsating B stars
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey X: Evidence for a bimodal distribution of rotational velocities for the single early B-type stars
• Magnetic spots on hot massive stars
• Nonlinear Tides in Close Binary Systems
• Evidence for nonlinear resonant mode coupling in the Beta Cep star HD 180642 (V1449 Aql) from CoRoT space-based photometry
• Collective pulsational velocity broadening due to gravity modes as a physical explanation for macroturbulence in hot massive stars
• Internal Gravity Wave Excitation by Turbulent Convection
• Variability in the CoRoT photometry of three hot O-type stars. HD 46223, HD 46150 and HD 46966
• Three-Dimensional Simulations of Massive Stars: I. Wave Generation and Propagation
• γ Doradus stars as test of angular momentum transport models
• The Magnetic Furnace: Intense Core Dynamos in B-stars
• Gravity-Modes in ZZ Ceti Stars: IV. Amplitude Saturation by Parametric Instability
• On the photometric detection of Internal Gravity Waves in upper main-sequence stars I. Methodology and application to CoRoT targets
• Idealised hydrodynamic simulations of turbulent oxygen-burning shell convection in 4π geometry
• Envelope Convection, Surface Magnetism and Spots in A- and late B-type Stars
• The Observational Signatures of Convectively Excited Internal Gravity Modes in Main Sequence Stars
• Observational consequences of turbulent pressure in the envelopes of massive stars
• On magnetic inhibition of photospheric macro-turbulence generated in the iron-bump opacity zone of O-stars
• Impact of rotation on stochastic excitation of gravity and gravito-inertial waves in stars
• Stellar granulation as seen in disk-integrated intensity. II. Theoretical scaling relations compared with observations
• The energy flux spectrum of internal waves generated by turbulent convection
• Onset of Nonlinear Internal Gravity Waves in Intermediate-Mass Stars
• Stellar granulation as seen in disk-integrated intensity. I. Simplified theoretical modeling
• DAVs: Red edge and Outbursts
• A comprehensive study of young B stars in NGC 2264: I. Space photometry and asteroseismology

Cited by in corpus (37)

• Dedalus: A Flexible Framework for Numerical Simulations with Spectral Methods
• Variability of OB stars from TESS southern Sectors 1-13 and high-resolution IACOB and OWN spectroscopy
• Photometric detection of internal gravity waves in upper main-sequence stars. II. Combined TESS photometry and high-resolution spectroscopy
• Fully compressible simulations of waves and core convection in main-sequence stars
• On the Origin of Stochastic, Low-Frequency Photometric Variability in Massive Stars
• A helium-flash-induced mixing event can explain the lithium abundances of red clump stars
• Variability of newly identified B-type stars observed by Kepler
• Stochastic Low Frequency Variability in 3-Dimensional Radiation Hydrodynamical Models of Massive Star Envelopes
• Stochastic light variations in hot stars from wind instability: Finding photometric signatures and testing against the TESS data
• An Atlas of Convection in Main-Sequence Stars
• The photometric variability of massive stars due to gravity waves excited by core convection
• Short Term Variability of Evolved Massive Stars with TESS II: A New Class of Cool, Pulsating Supergiants
• Core-Envelope Coupling in Intermediate-Mass Core-Helium Burning Stars
• Rossby numbers and stiffness values inferred from gravity-mode asteroseismology of rotating F- and B-type dwarfs: consequences for mixing, transport, magnetism, and convective penetration
• Photometric detection of internal gravity waves in upper main-sequence stars. III. Comparison of amplitude spectrum fitting and Gaussian process regression using celerite2
• Two-dimensional simulations of solar-like models with artificially enhanced luminosity. II. Impact on internal gravity waves
• Surface Manifestation of Stochastically Excited Internal Gravity Waves
• Short-term variability and mass loss in Be stars VI. Frequency groups in $\gamma$ Cas detected by TESS
• Three-Dimensional Simulations of Massive Stars: II. Age Dependence
• Two-dimensional simulations of internal gravity waves in a 5 $M_{\odot }$ Zero-Age-Main-Sequence model
• Multidimensional Simulations of Core Convection
• A Transparent Window into Early-Type Stellar Variability
• Three Dimensional Natures of Massive Star Envelopes
• The ESO UVES/FEROS Large Programs of TESS OB pulsators. I. Global stellar parameters from high-resolution spectroscopy
• Similar but different: the varied landscape of Onfp/Oef stars variability
• Impact of radial truncation on global 2D hydrodynamic simulations for a Sun-like model
• Five years of BRITE-Constellation photometry of the luminous blue variable P Cygni: properties of the stochastic low-frequency variability
• Discovery and Characterization of a Rare Magnetic Hybrid $\beta$ Cephei Slowly Pulsating B-type Star in an Eclipsing Binary in the Young Open Cluster NGC 6193
• The ESO UVES/FEROS Large Programs of TESS OB pulsators. II. On the physical origin of macroturbulence
• Inertial and gravity wave transmissions near radiative-convective boundaries
• Diving into the magnetosphere of the Of?p star HD108
• Ultraviolet Spectropolarimetry with Polstar: Clumping and Mass-loss Rate Corrections
• The shape of convection in 2D and 3D global simulations of stellar interiors
• Effects of stratification on overshooting and waves atop the convective core of $5M_{\odot }$ main-sequence stars
• A self-consistent numerical model of internal wave-induced mean flow oscillations in polar geometry
• Variability of Galactic blue supergiants observed with TESS
• Fast optical variability in Supergiant X-ray binaries