Variational principles and thermodynamics

Abstract

Variational principles play a fundamental role in deriving evolution equations of physics. They are working well in case of nondissipative evolution but for dissipative systems they are not unique, not predictive and not constructive. With methods of modern nonequilibrium thermodynamics, one can derive evolution equations for dissipative phenomena and, surprisingly, can also reproduce the Euler-Lagrange form of the evolution equations for ideal processes. In this work, we examine some demonstrative examples and compare thermodynamic and variational techniques. Then, we argue that instead of searching for variational principles for dissipative systems, a different program can be more fruitful: the second law alone can be an effective tool to construct both dissipative and nondissipative evolution equations.

References in corpus (16)

• On the Origin of Gravity and the Laws of Newton
• The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
• Emergent Gravity and the Dark Universe
• The fourth law of thermodynamics: steepest entropy ascent
• Can material time derivative be objective?
• Classical and quantum effective theories
• Thermodynamical extension of a symplectic numerical scheme with half space and time shift demonstrated on rheological waves in solids
• Quantum Field Theory as a Faithful Image of Nature
• Gradient and GENERIC evolution towards reduced dynamics
• Galilean relativistic fluid mechanics
• Properties of Conservation-dissipation Formalism of Irreversible Thermodynamics
• Bound states in Functional Renormalization Group
• A Variational Procedure for Time-Dependent Processes
• Is spontaneous wave function collapse testable at all?
• Weak invariants in dissipative systems: Action principle and Noether charge for kinetic theory
• Entropy production in phase field theories

Cited by in corpus (6)

• Nonequilibrium thermodynamics: emergent and fundamental
• Holographic fluids: a thermodynamic road to quantum physics
• Toward a Universal Theory of Stable Evolution
• A case study of non-Fourier heat conduction using Internal Variables and GENERIC
• Weak invariants in dissipative systems: Action principle and Noether charge for kinetic theory
• Stability of thermally bistable states and their switching in superconducting weak link