Deriving phase field crystal theory from dynamical density functional theory: consequences of the approximations

Abstract

Phase field crystal (PFC) theory, extensively used for modelling the structure of solids, can be derived from dynamical density functional theory (DDFT) via a sequence of approximations. Standard derivations neglect a term of form $\nabla \cdot [n\nabla Ln]$, where $n$ is the scaled density profile and $L$ is a linear operator. We show that this term makes a significant contribution to the stability of the crystal, and dropping this term from the theory forces another approximation, that of replacing the logarithmic term from the ideal gas contribution to the free energy with its truncated Taylor expansion, to yield a polynomial in $n$. However, the consequences of doing this are the presence of an additional spinodal in the phase diagram, so the liquid is predicted first to freeze and then to melt again as the density is increased; and other periodic structures are erroneously predicted to be thermodynamic equilibria. A second approximation is to replace $L$ by a gradient expansion. This leads to the possibility of solutions failing to exist above a certain value of the average density. We illustrate these conclusions with a simple model two-dimensional fluid. The consequences of the PFC approximations are that the phase diagram is both qualitatively incorrect, in that it has a stripe phase, and quantitatively incorrect (by orders of magnitude) regarding the properties of the crystal. Thus, although PFC models are successful as phenomenological models of crystallisation, we find it impossible to derive the PFC model as an accurate approximation to DDFT, without introducing spurious artefacts. However, making a simple one-mode approximation for the logarithm of the density distribution is surprisingly accurate, which gives a tantalising hint that accurate PFC-type theories may instead be derived for the field $\log (\rho (x))$, rather than for the density profile itself.

28 pages, 9 figures, to appear in Physical Review E

References in corpus (37)

• Modeling Elasticity in Crystal Growth
• Modeling Elastic and Plastic Deformations in Non-Equilibrium Processing Using Phase Field Crystals
• Dynamic Density Functional Theory of Fluids
• Dynamical density functional theory and its application to spinodal decomposition
• Phase-field-crystal models for condensed matter dynamics on atomic length and diffusive time scales: an overview
• Dynamical density functional theory for interacting Brownian particles: stochastic or deterministic?
• Derivation of the phase field crystal model for colloidal solidification
• Phase behavior of a fluid with competing attractive and repulsive interactions
• Phase-field crystal modeling of equilibrium bcc-liquid interfaces
• Phase-field-crystal model for fcc ordering
• Dynamical density functional theory for molecular and colloidal fluids: a microscopic approach to fluid mechanics
• Pattern formation with a conservation law
• Polymorphism, crystal nucleation and growth in the phase-field crystal model in 2d and 3d
• Long-time behaviour and phase transitions for the McKean--Vlasov equation on the torus
• Stability of Quasicrystals Composed of Soft Isotropic Particles
• Phase field crystal dynamics for binary systems: Derivation from dynamical density functional theory, amplitude equation formalism, and applications to alloy heterostructures
• Localized states in the conserved Swift-Hohenberg equation with cubic nonlinearity
• Dynamical density functional theory for dense atomic liquids
• Growth modes of quasicrystals
• Solidification fronts in supercooled liquids: how rapid fronts can lead to disordered glassy solids
• Microscopically-resolved simulations prove the existence of soft cluster crystals
• Three-dimensional Phase Field Quasicrystals
• Controlling crystal symmetries in phase-field crystal models
• Solidification in soft-core fluids: disordered solids from fast solidification fronts
• Bimodal grain-size scaling of thermal transport in polycrystalline graphene from large-scale molecular dynamics simulations
• Hexatic phase and cluster crystals of two-dimensional GEM4 spheres
• Phase-field crystal model for ordered crystals
• The overdamped limit of dynamic density functional theory: Rigorous results
• Modelling fluids and crystals using a two-component modified phase field crystal model
• Multiple-scale structures: from Faraday waves to soft-matter quasicrystals
• Eighth-order phase-field-crystal model for two-dimensional crystallization
• A phase-field-crystal approach to critical nuclei
• Angle-adjustable density field formulation for modeling crystalline microstructures
• Crystallisation of soft matter under confinement at interfaces and in wedges
• Elastic constants of stressed and unstressed materials in the phase field crystal model
• Dynamics of the Desai-Zwanzig model in multi-well and random energy landscapes
• Density functional theory for the crystallization of two-dimensional dipolar colloidal alloys

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Classical dynamical density functional theory: from fundamentals to applications
• A coarse-grained phase-field crystal model of plastic motion
• From a microscopic inertial active matter model to the Schrödinger equation
• A phase field crystal theory of the kinematics of dislocation lines
• First order phase transitions and the thermodynamic limit
• Two-dimensional localized states in an active phase-field-crystal model
• Jerky active matter: a phase field crystal model with translational and orientational memory
• Perspective: New directions in dynamical density functional theory
• Field Dislocation Mechanics and Phase Field Crystal models
• Quasicrystal formation in binary soft matter mixtures
• Efficient calculation of phase coexistence and phase diagrams: application to a binary phase-field crystal model
• Rectangle--triangle soft-matter quasicrystals with hexagonal symmetry
• Complex-tensor theory of simple smectics
• Derivation and analysis of a phase field crystal model for a mixture of active and passive particles
• A Unified Theory of Free Energy Functionals and Applications to Diffusion
• Density Distribution in Soft Matter Crystals and Quasicrystals
• Hyperuniform interfaces in non-equilibrium phase coexistence
• Amplitude expansion of the phase-field crystal model for complex crystal structures
• Elasticity versus phase field driven motion in the phase field crystal model
• Thermodynamics, formation dynamics and structural correlations in the bulk amorphous phase of the phase-field crystal model
• Exploring Bifurcations in Bose-Einstein Condensates via Phase Field Crystal Models
• Microscopic Patterns in the 2D Phase-Field-Crystal Model
• Gradient elasticity in Swift-Hohenberg and phase-field crystal models
• Structural phase-field crystal model for Lennard-Jones pair interaction potential
• Mesoscale modeling of deformations and defects in thin crystalline sheets
• Motility-induced crystallization and rotating crystallites
• Ginzburg-Landau amplitude equation for nonlinear nonlocal models
• Dynamical field theories for biaxial liquid crystals
• Elasticity in crystals with high density of local defects : insights from ultra-soft colloids