What Are Observables in Hamiltonian Einstein-Maxwell Theory?
arXiv:1907.09473 · doi:10.1007/s10701-019-00284-w
Abstract
Is change missing in Hamiltonian Einstein-Maxwell theory? Given the most common definition of observables (having weakly vanishing Poisson bracket with each first-class constraint), observables are constants of the motion and nonlocal. Unfortunately this definition also implies that the observables for massive electromagnetism with gauge freedom (Stueckelberg) are inequivalent to those of massive electromagnetism without gauge freedom (Proca). The alternative Pons-Salisbury-Sundermeyer definition of observables, aiming for Hamiltonian-Lagrangian equivalence, uses the gauge generator G, a tuned sum of first-class constraints, rather than each first-class constraint separately, and implies equivalent observables for equivalent massive electromagnetisms. For General Relativity, G generates 4-dimensional Lie derivatives for solutions. The Lie derivative compares different space-time points with the same coordinate value in different coordinate systems, like 1 a.m. summer time vs. 1 a.m. standard time, so a vanishing Lie derivative implies constancy rather than covariance. Requiring equivalent observables for equivalent formulations of massive gravity confirms that must generate the -dimensional Lie derivative (not ) for observables. These separate results indicate that observables are invariant under internal gauge symmetries but covariant under external gauge symmetries, but can this bifurcated definition work for mixed theories such as Einstein-Maxwell theory? Pons, Salisbury and Shepley have studied for Einstein-Yang-Mills. For Einstein-Maxwell, both and are invariant under electromagnetic gauge transformations and covariant (changing by a Lie derivative) under -dimensional coordinate transformations. Using the bifurcated definition, these quantities count as observables, as one would expect on non-Hamiltonian grounds.
arXiv commentForthcoming in _Foundations of Physics_
References in corpus (23)
- Photon and Graviton Mass Limits
- Partial observables
- Partial and Complete Observables for Hamiltonian Constrained Systems
- Gauge transformations in the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms of generally covariant theories
- Gravitational Observables and Local Symmetries
- Canonical Quantum Gravity
- GPS observables in general relativity
- Relational Observables in Gravity: a Review
- Beables/Observables in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Constraints and gauge transformations: Dirac's theorem is not always valid
- A First Class Constraint Generates Not a Gauge Transformation, But a Bad Physical Change: The Case of Electromagnetism
- Change in Hamiltonian General Relativity from the Lack of a Time-like Killing Vector Field
- Observables in classical canonical gravity: folklore demystified
- Slightly Bimetric Gravitation
- The issue of time in generally covariant theories and the Komar-Bergmann approach to observables in general relativity
- The present moment in quantum cosmology: challenges to the arguments for the elimination of time
- Permanent Underdetermination from Approximate Empirical Equivalence in Field Theory: Massless and Massive Scalar Gravity, Neutrino, Electromagnetic, Yang-Mills and Gravitational Theories
- Gauge Transformations in Einstein-Yang-Mills Theories
- Schrodinger Evolution for the Universe: Reparametrization
- Massive Supergravity and Deconstruction
- Léon Rosenfeld's general theory of constrained Hamiltonian dynamics
- Equivalent Theories Redefine Hamiltonian Observables to Exhibit Change in General Relativity
- Equivalent Theories and Changing Hamiltonian Observables in General Relativity