Updating Maxwell with Electrons, Charge, and More Realistic Polarization
arXiv:1904.09695 · doi:10.31224/osf.io/urxgs
Abstract
Maxwell's equations describe the relation of charge and electric force almost perfectly even though electrons and permanent charge were not in his equations, as he wrote them. For Maxwell, all charge depended on electric field. Charge was induced and polarization was described by a single dielectric constant. Electrons, permanent charge, and polarization are important when matter is involved. Polarization of matter cannot be described by a single dielectric constant with reasonable realism today. Only vacuum is well described by a single dielectric constant . Here, Maxwell's equations are rewritten to include permanent charge and any type of polarization. Rewriting is in one sense petty, and in another sense profound, in either case presumptuous. Rewriting confirms the legitimacy of electrodynamics. One cannot be sure ahead of time that a theory of electrodynamics without electrons or permanent charge (like Maxwell's equations as he wrote them) would be legitimate or not. After all, a theory cannot calculate the fields produced by charges (for example, electrons) that are not in the theory at all! After updating: (1) Maxwell's equations seem universal and exact. (2) Polarization must be described explicitly to use Maxwell`s equations in applications. (3) Conservation of total current (including displacement current ) becomes exact, independent of matter, allowing precise definition of electromotive force EMF in circuits.(4) Kirchhoff's current law becomes as exact as Maxwell`s equations themselves. (5) Conservation of total current needs to be satisfied in a wide variety of systems where it has not traditionally received much attention. (6) Classical chemical kinetics is seen to need revision to conserve current.
arXiv commentVersion 2 & 3 have typos corrected, minor revisions in text and references. Versions 4-6 have some new ideas. Version 7 has an important typo corrected on p. 13, after eq 1
References in corpus (25)
- Diffuse-Charge Dynamics in Electrochemical Systems
- From Structure to Function in Open Ionic Channels
- Resolution of the Abraham-Minkowski Controversy
- Poisson-Nernst-Planck Systems for Narrow Tubular-like Membrane Channels
- Electromagnetic energy-momentum and forces in matter
- An Energetic Variational Approach for ion transport
- Dielectric spectroscopy of water at low frequencies: The existence of an isopermitive point
- Diffusion limit of kinetic equations for multiple species charged particles
- Dynamics of Current, Charge and Mass
- A gentle introduction to the foundations of classical electrodynamics: The meaning of the excitations (D,H) and the field strengths (E, B)
- Asking Biological Questions of Physical Systems: the Device Approach to Emergent Properties
- Permeation as a Diffusion Process
- What Current Flows Through a Resistor?
- Osmosis through a Semi-permeable Membrane: a Consistent Approach to Interactions
- Atomic Biology, Electrostatics, and Ionic Channels
- Life's Solutions are Not Ideal
- Dielectric Dilemma
- The pedagogical value of the four-dimensional picture II: Another way of looking at the electromagnetic field
- Maxwell Matters
- Energetics of ion competition in the DEKA selectivity filter of neuronal sodium channels
- Life's Solutions are Complex Fluids. A Mathematical Challenge
- Kirchhoff's Law Can Be Exact
- Mass Action and Conservation of Current
- BITLLES: Electron Transport Simulation with Quantum Trajectories
- The Theory of Electrodynamics in a Linear Dielectric
Cited by in corpus (4)
- Molecular Mean-Field Theory of Ionic Solutions: a Poisson-Nernst-Planck-Bikerman Model
- Simulation of gating currents of the Shaker K channel using a Brownian model of the voltage sensor
- Electrodynamics Correlates Knock-on and Knock-off: Current is Spatially Uniform in Ion Channels
- Kirchhoff's Law Can Be Exact