Microscopic anisotropy misestimation in spherical-mean single diffusion encoding MRI

Abstract

Purpose: Microscopic fractional anisotropy (μFA) can disentangle microstructural information from orientation dispersion. While double diffusion encoding (DDE) MRI methods are widely used to extract accurate μFA, it has only recently been proposed that powder-averaged single diffusion encoding (SDE) signals, when coupled with the diffusion standard model (SM) and a set of constraints, could be used for μFA estimation. This study aims to evaluate μFA as derived from the spherical mean technique (SMT) set of constraints, as well as more generally for powder-averaged SM signals. Methods: SDE experiments were performed at 16.4 T on an ex vivo mouse brain (Δ/δ = 12/1.5 ms). The μFA maps obtained from powder-averaged SDE signals were then compared to maps obtained from DDE-MRI experiments (Δ/τ/δ = 12/12/1.5 ms), which allow a model-free estimation of μFA. Theory and simulations that consider different types of heterogeneity are presented for corroborating the experimental findings. Results: μFA, as well as other estimates derived from powder-averaged SDE signals produced large deviations from the ground truth in both gray and white matter. Simulations revealed that these misestimations are likely a consequence of factors not considered by the underlying microstructural models (such as intercomponent and intracompartmental kurtosis). Conclusion: Powder-averaged SMT and (2-component) SM are unable to accurately report μFA and other microstructural parameters in ex vivo tissues. Improper model assumptions and constraints can significantly compromise parameter specificity. Further developments and validations are required prior to implementation of these models in clinical or preclinical research.

References in corpus (5)

• Rotationally-invariant mapping of scalar and orientational metrics of neuronal microstructure with diffusion MRI
• Diffusion time dependence of microstructural parameters in fixed spinal cord
• What dominates the time dependence of diffusion transverse to axons: Intra- or extra-axonal water?
• Accurate estimation of microscopic diffusion anisotropy and its time dependence in the mouse brain
• Mapping axonal density and average diameter using non-monotonic time-dependent gradient-echo MRI

Cited by in corpus (13)

• Diffusion time dependence, power-law scaling, and exchange in gray matter
• Whole-brain diffusional variance decomposition (DIVIDE): Demonstration of technical feasibility at clinical MRI systems
• Free water DTI estimates from single b-value data might seem plausible but must be interpreted with care
• Correlation Tensor Magnetic Resonance Imaging
• Double diffusion encoding and applications for biomedical imaging
• Quantifying human gray matter microstructure using NEXI and 300 mT/m gradients
• SANDI: a compartment-based model for non-invasive apparent soma and neurite imaging by diffusion MRI
• Evidence for microscopic kurtosis in neural tissue revealed by Correlation Tensor MRI
• Validation and noise robustness assessment of microscopic anisotropy estimation with clinically feasible double diffusion encoding MRI
• Portable simulation framework for diffusion MRI
• Advanced encoding methods in diffusion MRI
• SpinDoctor: a Matlab toolbox for diffusion MRI simulation
• Diffusion Dispersion Imaging: Mapping OGSE Frequency Dependence in the Human Brain