Modern stellar spectroscopy caveats

Abstract

Multiple codes are available to derive atmospheric parameters and individual chemical abundances from high-resolution spectra of AFGKM stars. Almost all spectroscopists have their own preferences regarding which code and method to use. But the intrinsic differences between codes and methods lead to complex systematics that depend on multiple variables such as the selected spectral regions and the radiative transfer code used. I expand iSpec, a popular open-source spectroscopic tool, to support the most well-known radiative transfer codes and assess their similarities and biases when using multiple set-ups based on the equivalent-width method and the synthetic spectral-fitting technique (interpolating from a pre-computed grid of spectra or synthesizing with interpolated model atmospheres). This work shows that systematic differences on atmospheric parameters and abundances between most of the codes can be reduced when using the same method and executing a careful spectral feature selection. However, it may not be possible to ignore the remaining differences, depending on the particular case and the required precision. Regarding methods, equivalent-width-based and spectrum-fitting analyses exhibit large differences that are caused by their intrinsic differences, which is significant given the popularity of these two methods. The results help to identify the key caveats of modern spectroscopy that all scientists should be aware of before trusting their own results or being tempted to combine atmospheric parameters and abundances from the literature.

accepted for publication in MNRAS (language corrections in v2)

References in corpus (14)

• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• Determining stellar atmospheric parameters and chemical abundances of FGK stars with iSpec
• Stellar Abundances in the Solar Neighborhood: The Hypatia Catalog
• Gaia-ESO Survey: The analysis of high-resolution UVES spectra of FGK-type stars
• Automated derivation of stellar atmospheric parameters and chemical abundances: the MATISSE algorithm
• The Gaia FGK Benchmark Stars - High resolution spectral library
• Atomic and Molecular Data for Optical Stellar Spectroscopy
• ZASPE: A Code to Measure Stellar Atmospheric Parameters and their Covariance from Spectra
• A Comparison of Stellar Elemental Abundance Techniques and Measurements
• Geometry of giant star model atmospheres: A consistency test
• Testing the chemical tagging technique with open clusters
• OCCASO II. Physical parameters and Fe abundances of Red Clump stars in 18 Open Clusters
• Atmospheric stellar parameters for large surveys using FASMA, a new spectral synthesis package
• How uncertainties on stellar atmospheric parameters impact exoplanet studies?

Cited by in corpus (51)

• Confirmation of WASP-107b's extended Helium atmosphere with Keck II/NIRSPEC
• A Tendency Toward Alignment in Single-Star Warm Jupiter Systems
• RASSINE: Interactive tool for normalising stellar spectra I. Description and performance of the code
• Evidence that the Hot Jupiter WASP-77 A b Formed Beyond Its Parent Protoplanetary Disk's H2O Ice Line
• Differential abundances of open clusters and their tidal tails: chemical tagging and chemical homogeneity
• Host star metallicity of directly imaged wide-orbit planets: implications for planet formation
• The detailed chemical abundance patterns of accreted halo stars from the optical to infrared
• TOI-1759 b: a transiting sub-Neptune around a low mass star characterized with SPIRou and TESS
• The (im)possibility of strong chemical tagging
• TESS Cycle 1 observations of roAp stars with 2-min cadence data
• Periodic variable A-F spectral type stars in the northern TESS continuous viewing zone
• Purveyors of fine halos. II. Chemodynamical association of halo stars with Milky Way globular clusters
• Ondr}ejov echelle spectrograph, ground based support facility for exoplanet missions
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs: Not-so-fine hyperfine-split vanadium lines in cool star spectra
• The Most Metal-poor Stars in the Inner Bulge
• Discovery of one neutron star candidate from radial velocity monitoring
• Milky Way archaeology using RR Lyrae and type II Cepheids I. The Orphan stream in 7D using RR Lyrae stars
• High-resolution spectroscopic analysis of a large sample of Li-rich giants found by LAMOST
• The White Dwarf Binary Pathways Survey -- IX. Three long period white dwarf plus subgiant binaries
• Searching for new solar twins: The Inti survey for the Northern Sky
• Forecasting Chemical Abundance Precision for Extragalactic Stellar Archaeology
• The Epoch of Giant Planet Migration Planet Search Program. I. Near-Infrared Radial Velocity Jitter of Young Sun-like Stars
• Stellar atmospheric parameters of FGK-type stars from high-resolution optical and near-infrared CARMENES spectra
• A Roche Lobe-filling hot Subdwarf and White Dwarf Binary: possible detection of an ejected common envelope
• Homogeneous Transit Timing Analyses of Ten Exoplanet Systems
• Magnetic activity and evolution of the four Hyades K giants
• A search for runaway stars in twelve Galactic supernova remnants
• Multiple stellar populations at less evolved stages: detection of chemical variations among main-sequence dwarfs in NGC 1978
• Fundamental effective temperature measurements for eclipsing binary stars -- III. SPIRou near-infrared spectroscopy and CHEOPS photometry of the benchmark G0V star EBLM J0113+31
• The Chemical Composition of Extreme-Velocity Stars
• Low-mass members of nearby young stellar moving groups from Gaia EDR3
• A celestial matryoshka: Dynamical and spectroscopic analysis of the Albireo system
• NGTS 15b, 16b, 17b and 18b: four hot Jupiters from the Next Generation Transit Survey
• HERMES spectroscopy of normal A and Am stars
• Bright Spectroscopic Binaries: I. Orbital parameters of five systems with periods of P < 365 days
• A spectroscopic follow-up for Gaia19bld
• The discovery of three hot Jupiters, NGTS-23b, 24b and 25b, and updated parameters for HATS-54b from the Next Generation Transit Survey
• Li-rich giant stars under scrutiny: Binarity, magnetic activity and the evolutionary status after Gaia DR2
• Fundamental effective temperature measurements for eclipsing binary stars -- II. The detached F-type eclipsing binary CPD-54 810
• Spectroscopic and photometric time series of the bright RRc star T Sex
• Rapidly rotating stars and their transiting planets: KELT-17b, KELT-19Ab, and KELT-21b in the CHEOPS and TESS era
• Chemically Peculiar Stars in the Open Cluster Stock 2
• KIC 12268220: A $\delta$ Scuti Pulsating Star and an Active Protohelium White Dwarf in an Eclipsing Binary System
• Photometric and spectroscopic studies of the long period low mass ratio deep contact binary KN Per
• A detailed study of the barium central star of the planetary nebula Abell 70
• New Temperature and Metallicity Scale of Cool Giants from K-band Spectra
• Bright Spectroscopic Binaries: II. A study of five systems with orbital periods of P < 500 days
• KIC 6951642: confirmed Kepler $\gamma$ Doradus-$\delta$ Scuti star with intermediate to fast rotation in a possible single-lined binary system
• KIC 10417986: Spectroscopic confirmation of the nature of the binary system with a δ Scuti component
• A statistical method for the identification of stars enriched in neutron-capture elements from medium-resolution spectra
• HD 183986: a high-contrast SB2 system with a pulsating component