Surprised by the Hot Hand Fallacy? A Truth in the Law of Small Numbers

Abstract

We prove that a subtle but substantial bias exists in a common measure of the conditional dependence of present outcomes on streaks of past outcomes in sequential data. The magnitude of this streak selection bias generally decreases as the sequence gets longer, but increases in streak length, and remains substantial for a range of sequence lengths often used in empirical work. We observe that the canonical study in the influential hot hand fallacy literature, along with replications, are vulnerable to the bias. Upon correcting for the bias we find that the long-standing conclusions of the canonical study are reversed.

Cited by in corpus (8)

• The Hot Hand in Professional Darts
• The causal effect of a timeout at stopping an opposing run in the NBA
• Predictive Bayesian selection of multistep Markov chains, applied to the detection of the hot hand and other statistical dependencies in free throws
• Continuous-time state-space modelling of the hot hand in basketball
• A Fresh Look at the "Hot Hand" Paradox
• Can the hot hand phenomenon be modelled? A Bayesian hidden Markov approach
• The Hot Hand in Actual Game Situations
• The Hot Hand and Its Effect on the NBA