Critical states in Political Trends. How much reliable is a poll on Twitter? A study by means of the Potts Model

Abstract

In recent years, Twitter data related to political trends have tentatively been used to make predictions (poll) about several electoral events. Given $q$ candidates for an election and a time-series of Twitts (short messages), one can extract the $q$ mean trends and the $q(q+1)/2$ Twitt-to-Twitt correlations, and look for the statistical models that reproduce these data. On the base of several electoral events and assuming a stationary regime, we find out the following: i) the maximization of the entropy singles out a microscopic model (single-Twitt-level) that coincides with a $q$-state Potts model having suitable couplings and external fields to be determined via an inverse problem from the two sets of data; ii) correlations decay as $1/N_{eff}$, where $N_{eff}$ is a small fraction of the mean number of Twitts; iii) the simplest statistical models that reproduce these correlations are the multinomial distribution (MD), characterized by $q$ external fields, and the mean-field Potts model (MFP), characterized by one coupling; iv) remarkably, this coupling turns out to be always close to its critical value. This results in a MD or MFP model scenario that discriminates between cases in which polls are reliable and not reliable, respectively. More precisely, predictions based on polls should be avoided whenever the data maps to a MFP because anomalous large fluctuations (if $q=2$) or sudden jumps (if $q\ge 3$) in the trends might take place as a result of a second-order or a first-order phase transition of the MFP, respectively.

arXiv comment14 pages, 14 figures

References in corpus (10)

• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Theory of Rumour Spreading in Complex Social Networks
• The statistical mechanics of networks
• Scaling and universality in proportional elections
• "I Wanted to Predict Elections with Twitter and all I got was this Lousy Paper" -- A Balanced Survey on Election Prediction using Twitter Data
• Sznajd model and its applications
• A sentiment analysis of Singapore Presidential Election 2011 using Twitter data with census correction
• Election results and the Sznajd model on Barabasi network
• The Spread of Opinions and Proportional Voting
• Stylized facts in Brazilian vote distributions

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Gibbs measures of Potts model on Cayley trees: a survey and applications
• 1D Three-state mean-field Potts model with first- and second-order phase transitions
• Microcanonical Monte Carlo simulation of opinion dynamics under the influence of mass media
• Filter Bubbles, Echo Chambers, and Reinforcement: Tracing Populism in Election Data