The disc origin of the Milky Way bulge: On the necessity of the thick disc

Abstract

In the MW bulge, metal-rich stars form a strong bar and are more peanut-shaped than metal-poor stars. It has been recently claimed that this behavior is driven by the initial in-plane radial velocity dispersion of these populations, rather than by their initial vertical random motions. This has led to the suggestion that a thick disc is not necessary to explain the characteristics of the MW bulge. We rediscuss this issue by analyzing two dissipationless N-body simulations of boxy/peanut (b/p)-shaped bulges formed from composite stellar discs, made of kinematically cold and hot stellar populations, and we conclude that initial vertical random motions are as important as in-plane random motions in determining the relative contribution of cold and hot disc populations with height above the plane, the metallicity and age trends. Previous statements emphasizing the dominant role of in-plane motions in determining these trends are not confirmed. However, differences exist in the morphology and strength of the resulting b/p-shaped bulges: a model where disc populations have initially only different in-plane random motions, but similar thickness, results into a b/p bulge where all populations have a similar peanut shape, independently on their initial kinematics, or metallicity. We discuss the reasons behind these differences, and also predict the signatures that these two extreme initial conditions would leave on the vertical age and metallicity gradients of disc stars, outside the bulge region. We conclude that a metal-poor, kinematically (radial and vertical) hot component, that is a thick disc, is necessary in the MW before bar formation, supporting the scenario traced in previous works. [abridged]

arXiv comment17 pages, 16 figures, A&A, in press

References in corpus (52)

• The Geneva-Copenhagen survey of the Solar neighbourhood: Ages, metallicities, and kinematic properties of 14,000 F and G dwarfs
• The Geneva-Copenhagen Survey of the Solar neighbourhood III. Improved distances, ages, and kinematics
• The age structure of stellar populations in the solar vicinity. Clues of a two-phase formation history of the Milky Way disk
• Mapping the Three-Dimensional Density of the Galactic Bulge with VVV Red Clump Stars
• The Geneva-Copenhagen Survey of the Solar neighbourhood II. New uvby calibrations and rediscussion of stellar ages, the G dwarf problem, age-metallicity diagram, and heating mechanisms of the disk
• Dynamical modelling of the Galactic bulge and bar: the Milky Way's bar pattern speed, stellar, and dark matter mass distribution
• Our Milky Way as a Pure-Disk Galaxy -- A Challenge for Galaxy Formation
• The photometric structure of the inner Galaxy
• ARGOS III: Stellar Populations in the Galactic Bulge of the Milky Way
• Red giant masses and ages derived from carbon and nitrogen abundances
• The Bulge Radial Velocity Assay (BRAVA): II. Complete Sample and Data Release
• The stellar population structure of the Galactic disk
• Spectroscopic determination of masses (and implied ages) for red giants
• ARGOS IV: The Kinematics of the Milky Way Bulge
• The age-metallicity structure of the Milky Way disk
• Reconstructing the star formation history of the Milky Way disc(s) from chemical abundances
• Made-to-Measure models of the Galactic Box/Peanut bulge: stellar and total mass in the bulge region
• Separation of Stellar Populations by an Evolving Bar: Implications for the Bulge of the Milky Way
• The structure of the Galactic bar
• Modelling the Galactic bar using OGLE-II Red Clump Giant Stars
• The GIRAFFE Inner Bulge Survey (GIBS) III. Metallicity distributions and kinematics of 26 Galactic bulge fields
• When the Milky Way turned off the lights: APOGEE provides evidence of star formation quenching in our Galaxy
• The dominant epoch of star formation in the Milky Way formed the thick disc
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: metallicity and kinematic trends in the Milky Way bulge
• Kinematic modelling of the Milky Way using the RAVE and GCS stellar surveys
• A New Photometric Model of the Galactic Bar using Red Clump Giants
• Age velocity dispersion relations and heating histories in disc galaxies
• Re-visiting the relations: Galactic thin disc age-velocity dispersion relation
• The vertical motions of mono-abundance sub-populations in the Milky Way disk
• Before the Bar: Kinematic Detection of A Spheroidal Metal-Poor Bulge Component
• A boxy bulge in the Milky Way. Inversion of the stellar statistics equation with 2MASS data
• The disc origin of the Milky Way bulge: Dissecting the chemo-morphological relations using N-body simulations and APOGEE
• An Iterative Method for Constructing Equilibrium Phase Models of Stellar Systems
• Why the Milky Way's bulge is not only a bar formed from a cold thin disk
• Phylogeny of the Milky Way's inner disk and bulge populations: Implications for gas accretion, (the lack of) inside-out thick disk formation, and quenching
• Chemodynamical Modelling of the Galactic Bulge and Bar
• Mapping a stellar disk into a boxy bulge: The outside-in part of the Milky Way bulge formation
• Beyond Ellipse(s): Accurately Modelling the Isophotal Structure of Galaxies with $Isofit$ and $Cmodel$
• Metallicity gradients through disk Instability: A simple model for the Milky Way's boxy bulge
• The disc origin of the Milky Way bulge
• Metallicity-dependendent kinematics and morphology of the Milky Way bulge
• Quantifying the (X/Peanut)-Shaped Structure in Edge-on Disc Galaxies: Length, Strength, and Nested Peanuts
• Stars behind bars I: The Milky Way's central stellar populations
• What the Milky Way bulge reveals about the initial metallicity gradients in the disc
• Quantifying the (X/peanut)-shaped Structure of the Milky Way - New Constraints on the Bar Geometry
• Bars & boxy/peanut bulges in thin & thick discs: I. Morphology and line-of-sight velocities of a fiducial model
• The structural evolution of galaxies with both thin and thick discs
• Origin of chemical and dynamical properties of the Galactic thick disk
• Migration and kinematics in growing disc galaxies with thin and thick discs
• Peanut-shaped metallicity distributions in bulges of edge-on galaxies: the case of NGC 4710
• Searching for a kinematic signature of the moderately metal-poor stars in the Milky Way bulge using N-body simulations
• A new look at the kinematics of the bulge from an N-body model

Cited by in corpus (24)

• Bimodality of [α/Fe]-[Fe/H] distributions is a natural outcome of dissipative collapse and disc growth in Milky Way-type galaxies
• The Bar and Spiral Arms in the Milky Way: Structure and Kinematics
• Born this way: thin disc, thick disc, and isotropic spheroid formation in FIRE-2 Milky-Way-mass galaxy simulations
• Escapees from the bar resonances. On the presence of low-eccentricity, metal-rich stars at the Solar vicinity
• Chemo-kinematics of the Milky Way spiral arms and bar resonances: connection to ridges and moving groups in the Solar vicinity
• Predicting accreted satellite galaxy masses and accretion redshifts based on globular cluster orbits in the E-MOSAICS simulations
• Box/peanut-shaped bulges in action space
• Bars and boxy/peanut bulges in thin and thick discs. II. Can bars form in hot thick discs?
• A2A: 21,000 bulge stars from the ARGOS survey with stellar parameters on the APOGEE scale
• Simulating cosmological substructure in the solar neighbourhood
• The imprint of clump formation at high redshift. II. The chemistry of the bulge
• Buckling bars in nearly face-on galaxies observed with MaNGA
• The LMC impact on the kinematics of the Milky Way satellites: clues from the running solar apex
• Mapping the tilt of the Milky Way bulge velocity ellipsoids with ARGOS and $Gaia$ DR2
• Bars and boxy/peanut bulges in thin and thick discs III. Boxy/peanut bulge formation and evolution in presence of thick discs
• Double X/Peanut Structures in Barred Galaxies -- Insights from an $N$--body Simulation
• Blanco DECam Bulge Survey (BDBS) V. Cleaning the foreground populations from Galactic bulge colour-magnitude diagrams using Gaia EDR3
• Tailoring galaxies: size-luminosity-surface brightness relations of bulges and disks along the morphological sequence
• Rediscovering the Milky Way with orbit superposition approach and APOGEE data II. Chrono-chemo-kinematics of the disc
• Predicted Trends in Milky Way Bulge Proper Motion Rotation Curves: future Prospects for HST and LSST
• Search for the metal-weak thick disk from the LAMOST DR5
• Rediscovering the Milky Way with orbit superposition approach and APOGEE data III. Panoramic view of the bulge
• The chemical and spatial variations of the bulge's velocity ellipsoids
• Blanco DECam Bulge Survey (BDBS) IV: Metallicity Distributions and Bulge Structure from 2.6 Million Red Clump Stars