No unique solution to the seismological problem of standing kink MHD waves
arXiv:1812.07266 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201833813
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to point out that the classic seismological problem using observations and theoretical expressions for the periods and damping times of transverse standing magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves in coronal loops is better referred to as a reduced seismological problem. Reduced emphasises the fact that only a small number of characteristic quantities of the equilibrium profiles can be determined. Reduced also implies that there is no unique solution to the full seismological problem. Even the reduced seismological problem does not allow a unique solution. Bayesian inference results support our mathematical arguments and offer insight into the relationship between the algebraic and the probabilistic inversions.
arXiv comment10 pages, accepted in A&A
References in corpus (13)
- Time-Distance Seismology of the Solar Corona with CoMP
- On the nature of kink MHD waves in magnetic flux tubes
- Surface Alfven waves in solar flux tubes
- Selective spatial damping of propagating kink waves due to resonant absorption
- Analytic approximate seismology of transversely oscillating coronal loops
- Observational evidence of resonantly damped propagating kink waves in the solar corona
- The behavior of transverse waves in nonuniform solar flux tubes. I. Comparison of ideal and resistive results
- Damping of Fast Magnetohydrodynamic Oscillations in Quiescent Filament Threads
- The behavior of transverse waves in nonuniform solar flux tubes. II. Implications for coronal loop seismology
- Bayesian Coronal Seismology
- Bayesian Magnetohydrodynamic Seismology of Coronal Loops
- Model comparison for the density structure across solar coronal waveguides
- Determination of the cross-field density structuring in coronal waveguides using the damping of transverse waves
Cited by in corpus (13)
- Kink oscillations of coronal loops
- MHD Waves in open coronal structures
- Magnetohydrodynamic Fast Sausage Waves in the Solar Corona
- Magnetohydrodynamic Seismology of Quiet Solar Active Regions
- Weak damping of propagating MHD kink waves in the quiescent corona
- Kink Oscillations in Solar Coronal Loops with Elliptical Cross-Sections. I. the linear regime
- Novel data analysis techniques in coronal seismology
- Resonant absorption: transformation of compressive motions into vortical motions
- Resonant Damping of Kink Modes in Solar Coronal Slabs
- Bayesian evidence for a nonlinear damping model for coronal loop oscillations
- Standing Sausage Perturbations in solar coronal loops with diffuse boundaries: An initial-value-problem perspective
- Mixed properties of magnetohydrodynamic waves undergoing resonant absorption in the cusp continuum
- Global Coronal Magnetic Field Estimation Using Bayesian Inference