Distinguishing Artificial and Essential Symmetry Breaking in a Single Determinant: Approach and Application to the C${}_{60}$, C${}_{36}$, and C${}_{20}$ Fullerenes

Abstract

We present a thorough analysis of symmetry breaking observed in Hartree-Fock (HF) solutions of fullerenes C${}_{60}$, C${}_{36}$, and C${}_{20}$ in order to characterize the nature of electron correlation in them. Our analysis is based on (1) the critical regularization strength to restore symmetry breaking in the recently developed regularized orbital optimized second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory ($\kappa$-OOMP2), (2) singlet-triplet gaps from various MP2 methods, and (3) natural orbital occupation numbers from restricted coupled-cluster with singles and doubles (RCCSD) and coupled-cluster valence bond with singles and doubles (CCVB-SD). Based on these three independent probes, we conclude that C${}_{36}$ (D${}_{\text{6h}}$) exhibits genuine strong correlation and symmetry breaking whereas C${}_{60}$ exhibits {\it artificial} HF symmetry breaking and is not strongly correlated. Investigating the critical regularization strength, we discuss strong correlation in C${}_{20}$ at the Jahn-Teller distorted geometries (C${}_{\text{2h}}$, D${}_{\text{2h}}$, C${}_{\text{i}}$, and D${}_{\text{3h}}$) and the I${}_{\text{h}}$ geometry. Only C${}_{20}$ (I${}_{\text{h}}$) was found to be strongly correlated while others exhibit {\it artificial} HF symmetry breaking. This analysis highlights a useful feature of the recommended $\kappa$-OOMP2 method. It is an electronic structure method that describes dynamic correlation, and attenuates strong correlation in MP2 towards zero by regularization. Therefore, $\kappa$-OOMP2 will exhibit symmetry breaking in its reference determinant only when correlation is strong (i.e., essential symmetry breaking). Artificial symmetry breaking (arising in HF due to neglect of dynamic correlation) is thus removed in $\kappa$-OOMP2.

References in corpus (3)

• Regularized Orbital-Optimized Second-Order Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory: A Reliable Fifth-Order Scaling Electron Correlation Model with Orbital Energy Dependent Regularizers
• Polyradical character and spin frustration in fullerene molecules: An ab initio non-collinear Hartree--Fock study
• Open-Shell Coupled-Cluster Valence-Bond Theory Augmented with an Independent Amplitude Approximation for Three-Pair Correlations: Application to a Model Oxygen-Evolving Complex and Single Molecular Magnet

Cited by in corpus (13)

• Drug design on quantum computers
• autoCAS: a program for fully automated multi-configurational calculations
• Systematically Improvable Tensor Hypercontraction: Interpolative Separable Density-Fitting for Molecules Applied to Exact Exchange, Second- and Third-Order Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory
• Excited States via Coupled Cluster Theory without Equation-of-Motion Methods: Seeking Higher Roots with Application to Doubly Excited States and Double Core Hole States
• Two Single-Reference Approaches to Singlet Biradicaloid Problems: Complex, Restricted Orbitals and Approximate Spin-Projection Combined With Regularized Orbital-Optimized Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory
• Predicting Ligand-Dissociation Energies of 3d Coordination Complexes with Auxiliary-Field Quantum Monte Carlo
• Third-Order Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory Made Useful? Choice of Orbitals and Scaling Greatly Improves Accuracy for Thermochemistry, Kinetics and Intermolecular Interactions
• Utilizing Essential Symmetry Breaking in Auxiliary-Field Quantum Monte Carlo: Application to the Spin Gaps of the C${}_{36}$ Fullerene and an Iron Porphyrin Model Complex
• Polishing the Gold Standard: The Role of Orbital Choice in CCSD(T) Vibrational Frequency Prediction
• Excited states, symmetry breaking, and unphysical solutions in state-specific CASSCF theory
• Making Many-Body Interactions Nearly Pairwise Additive: The Polarized Many-Body Expansion Approach
• Ground states of Heisenberg spin clusters from a cluster-based projected Hartree-Fock approach
• Exploring Spin Symmetry-Breaking Effects for Static Field Ionization of Atoms: Is There an Analog to the Coulson-Fischer Point in Bond Dissociation?