Well-behaved versus ill-behaved density functionals for single bond dissociation: Separating success from disaster functional by functional for stretched H${}_2$

Abstract

Unrestricted DFT methods are typically expected to describe the homolytic dissociation of nonpolar single bonds in neutral species with qualitative accuracy, due to the lack of significant delocalization error. We however find that many widely used density functional approximations fail to describe features along the dissociation curve of the simple H${}_2$ molecule. This is not an universal failure of DFT in the sense that many classic functionals like PBE and B3LYP give very reasonable results, as do some more modern methods like MS2. However, some other widely used functionals like B97-D (empirically fitted) and TPSS (non-empirically constrained) predict qualitatively wrong static polarizabilities, force constants and some even introduce an artificial barrier against association of independent H atoms to form H${}_2$. The polarizability and force constant prediction failures appear to stem from incomplete spin localization into individual H atoms beyond the Coulson-Fisher point, resulting in `fractionally bonded' species where the ionic contributions to the Slater determinant are not completely eliminated, unlike the case of unrestricted Hartree-Fock. These errors therefore appear to be a consequence of poor self-consistent density prediction by the problematic functional. The same reasons could potentially lead to spurious barriers towards H atom association, indirectly also leading to incorrect forces. These unphysicalities suggest that the use of problematic functionals is probably unwise in \textit{ab initio} dynamics calculations, especially if strong electrostatic interactions are possible.

References in corpus (14)

• Climbing the Density Functional Ladder: Non-Empirical Meta-Generalized Gradient Approximation Designed for Molecules and Solids
• Localization and delocalization errors in density functional theory and implications for band-gap prediction
• Fractional charge perspective on the band-gap in density-functional theory
• Understanding and reducing errors in density functional calculations
• How accurate is density functional theory at predicting dipole moments? An assessment using a new database of 200 benchmark values
• Fractional spins and static correlation error in density functional theory
• Describing static correlation in bond dissociation by Kohn-Sham density functional theory
• SCAN-based hybrid and double-hybrid density functionals from models without fitted parameters
• Semilocal and Hybrid Meta-Generalized Gradient Approximations Based on the Understanding of the Kinetic-Energy-Density Dependence
• Delocalization errors in density functional theory are essentially quadratic in fractional occupation number
• Regularized Orbital-Optimized Second-Order Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory: A Reliable Fifth-Order Scaling Electron Correlation Model with Orbital Energy Dependent Regularizers
• Ions in solution: Density Corrected Density Functional Theory (DC-DFT)
• Density Functional Model for Nondynamic and Strong Correlation
• xDH double hybrid functionals can be qualitatively incorrect for non-equilibrium geometries: Dipole moment inversion and barriers to radical-radical association using XYG3 and XYGJ-OS

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Excited state orbital optimization via minimizing the square of the gradient: General approach and application to singly and doubly excited states via density functional theory
• Highly Accurate Prediction of Core Spectra of Molecules at Density Functional Theory Cost: Attaining sub eV Error from a Restricted Open-Shell Kohn-Sham Approach
• Accurate prediction of core-level spectra of radicals at density functional theory cost via square gradient minimization and recoupling of mixed configurations
• Third order Møller-Plesset theory made more useful? The role of density functional theory orbitals
• Beyond the Coulson-Fischer point: Characterizing single excitation CI and TDDFT for excited states in single bond dissociations
• Too big, too small or just right? A benchmark assessment of density functional theory for predicting the spatial extent of the electron density of small chemical systems
• Exploring Spin Symmetry-Breaking Effects for Static Field Ionization of Atoms: Is There an Analog to the Coulson-Fischer Point in Bond Dissociation?
• Locating Ab Initio Transition States via Approximate Geodesics on Machine Learned Potential Energy Surfaces