Seven Problems with the Claims Related to the Hubble Tension in arXiv:1810.02595

Abstract

Shanks et al. (2018) arXiv:1810.02595 make two claims that they argue bring the local measurement and early Universe prediction of H0 into agreement: A) they claim that Gaia DR2 parallax measurements show the geometric calibration of the Cepheid distance scale used to measure H0 to be grossly in error and B) that we live near the middle of an enormous void, further biasing the local measurement of the Hubble constant. We show that the first claim is caused by five erroneous uses of the data: in decreasing order of importance: 1) the use of a distance indicator, main sequence fitting of cluster stars, which is unrelated to the calibration of Cepheids and therefore has no bearing on current measurements of H0; 2) the use of Gaia data for Cepheids that fully saturate the detector, producing unreliable parallaxes; 3) the use of a fixed parallax offset which is known to depend on source magnitude and color but which is derived for sources with extremely different colors and magnitudes; 4) ignoring the uncertainty in this offset; and 5) ignoring the other geometric sources of Cepheid calibration, the distance of the LMC from detached eclipsing binaries and the masers in NGC 4258, which are independent of Milky Way parallaxes. Just resolving the first two of these issues by not using unrelated or saturated data leads to no inconsistency between Gaia parallaxes and the current Cepheid distance scale. The second claim can be refuted 6) because of the increase in chi-squared that the alleged void would entail in SN measurements in the Hubble flow, and 7) because it would represent a 6 sigma fluctuation of cosmic variance between the local and globally measured expansion, requiring us to live in an exceedingly special location.

arXiv comment4 pages, 1 figure, response to arXiv:1810.02595

References in corpus (3)

• H0LiCOW - IX. Cosmographic analysis of the doubly imaged quasar SDSS 1206+4332 and a new measurement of the Hubble constant
• Should Type Ia Supernova Distances be Corrected for their Local Environments?
• GAIA Cepheid parallaxes and 'Local Hole' relieve $H_0$ tension

Cited by in corpus (14)

• $H_0$ from cosmic chronometers and Type Ia supernovae, with Gaussian Processes and the novel Weighted Polynomial Regression method
• Rock 'n' Roll Solutions to the Hubble Tension
• Observational evidence for a local underdensity in the Universe and its effect on the measurement of the Hubble Constant
• Neutrino Self-Interactions and Double Beta Decay
• CMB tensions with low-redshift $H_0$ and $S_8$ measurements: impact of a redshift-dependent type-Ia supernovae intrinsic luminosity
• Post-Newtonian limit of Teleparallel Horndeski gravity
• Quantifying the evidence for the current speed-up of the Universe with low and intermediate-redshift data. A more model-independent approach
• Exploring the evidence for a large local void with supernovae Ia data
• Three open clusters containing Cepheids: NGC 6649, NGC 6664 and Berkeley 55
• Local Hole revisited: evidence for bulk motions and self-consistent outflow
• The effects of peculiar velocities in SN Ia environments on the local $H_0$ measurement
• Towards Machine-assisted Meta-Studies: The Hubble Constant
• A gigaparsec-scale local void and the Hubble tension
• The $H_0$ and $S_8$ tensions necessitate early and late time changes to $\Lambda$CDM