A comparison of Alpha Particle and Proton Beam Differential flow in Collisionally Young Solar Wind

Abstract

In fast wind or when the local Coulomb collision frequency is low, observations show that solar wind minor ions and ion sub-populations flow with different bulk velocities. Measurements indicate that the drift speed of both alpha particles and proton beams with respect to the bulk or core protons rarely exceeds the local Alfvén speed, suggesting that a magnetic instability or other wave-particle process limits their maximum drift. We compare simultaneous alpha particle, proton beam, and proton core observations from instruments on the Wind spacecraft spanning over 20 years. In nearly collisionless solar wind, we find that the normalized alpha particle drift speed is slower than the normalized proton beam speed; no correlation between fluctuations in both species' drifts about their means; and a strong anti-correlation between collisional age and alpha-proton differential flow, but no such correlation with proton beam-core differential flow. Controlling for the collisional dependence, both species' normalized drifts exhibit similar statistical distributions. In the asymptotic, zero Coulomb collision limit, the youngest measured differential flows most strongly correlate with an approximation of the Alfvén speed that includes proton pressure anisotropy. In this limit and with this most precise representation, alpha particles drift at 67% and proton beam drift is approximately 105% of the local Alfvén speed. We posit that one of two physical explanations is possible. Either (1) an Alfvénic process preferentially accelerates or sustains proton beams and not alphas or (2) alpha particles are more susceptible to either an instability or Coulomb drag than proton beams.

9 pages, 9 figures, 1 table

References in corpus (4)

• The NumPy array: a structure for efficient numerical computation
• A zone of preferential ion heating extends tens of solar radii from Sun
• The Dispersion Relations and Instability Thresholds of Oblique Plasma Modes in the Presence of an Ion Beam
• Relative drifts and temperature anisotropies of protons and $\alpha$ particles in the expanding solar wind -- 2.5D hybrid simulations

Cited by in corpus (34)

• The multi-scale nature of the solar wind
• Parker Solar Probe observations of proton beams simultaneous with ion-scale waves
• Enhanced Energy Transfer Rate in Solar Wind Turbulence Observed near the Sun from Parker Solar Probe
• Inferred Linear Stability of Parker Solar Probe Observations using One- and Two-Component Proton Distributions
• Strong perpendicular velocity-space in proton beams observed by Parker Solar Probe
• Parallel-propagating Fluctuations at Proton-kinetic Scales in the Solar Wind are Dominated by Kinetic Instabilities
• The origin of slow Alfvénic solar wind at solar minimum
• Helium Variation Across Two Solar Cycles Reveals A Speed-Dependent Phase Lag
• Solar wind energy flux observations in the inner heliosphere: First results from Parker Solar Probe
• Modeling ion beams, kinetic instabilities, and waves observed by the Parker Solar Probe near perihelia
• The Structure and Origin of Switchbacks: Parker Solar Probe Observations
• Ion-Driven Instabilities in the Inner Heliosphere I: Statistical Trends
• Solar Wind Helium Abundance Heralds Solar Cycle Onset
• Parker Solar Probe Observations of High Plasma Beta Solar Wind from Streamer Belt
• Electromagnetic Ion-Ion Instabilities in Space Plasmas: Effects of Suprathermal Populations
• Compositional metrics of fast and slow Alfvenic solar wind emerging from coronal holes and their boundaries
• Dependence of Solar Wind Proton Temperature on the Polarisation Properties of Alfvénic Fluctuations at Ion-kinetic Scales
• Electromagnetic Proton Beam Instabilities in the Inner Heliosphere: Energy Transfer Rate, Radial Distribution, and Effective Excitation
• Density And Velocity Fluctuations of Alpha Particles in Magnetic Switchbacks
• Effects of alpha-proton differential flow on proton temperature anisotropy instabilities in the solar wind: Wind observations
• Dependence of ion temperatures on alpha-proton differential flow vector and heating mechanisms in the solar wind
• Intermittency and Ion Temperature-Anisotropy Instabilities: Simulation and Magnetosheath Observation
• The Contribution of Alpha Particles to the Solar Wind Angular Momentum Flux in the Inner Heliosphere
• Fully Kinetic Simulations of Proton-Beam-Driven Instabilities from Parker Solar Probe Observations
• Cross Helicity and the Helium Abundance as an in situ Metric of Solar Wind Acceleration
• Ion-Driven Instabilities in the Inner Heliosphere II: Classification and Multi-Dimensional Mapping
• The Temperature Anisotropy and Helium Abundance Features of Alfvénic Slow Solar Wind Observed by Parker Solar Probe, Helios, and Wind Missions
• Near subsonic solar wind outflow from an active region
• On the transition from Slow to Fast Wind as Observed in Composition Observations
• The Evolution of Heavy Ion Abundances with Solar Activity
• Evolution of an Alfvén Wave-Driven Proton Beam in the Expanding Solar Wind
• A powerful machine learning technique to extract proton core, beam and alpha-particle parameters from velocity distribution functions in space plasmas
• Characterizing the Impact of Alfvén Wave Forcing in Interplanetary Space on the Distribution of near-Earth Solar Wind Speeds
• On the Regulation of the Solar Wind Helium Abundance by the Hydrogen Compressibility