How accurately can we measure the reconnection rate $E_M$ for the MMS diffusion region event of 2017-07-11?

Abstract

We investigate the accuracy with which the reconnection electric field $E_M$ can be determined from in-situ plasma data. We study the magnetotail electron diffusion region observed by NASA's Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) on 2017-07-11 at 22:34 UT and focus on the very large errors in $E_M$ that result from errors in an $LMN$ boundary-normal coordinate system. We determine several $LMN$ coordinates for this MMS event using several different methods. We use these $M$ axes to estimate $E_M$. We find some consensus that the reconnection rate was roughly $E_M$=3.2 mV/m $\pm$ 0.06 mV/m, which corresponds to a normalized reconnection rate of $0.18\pm 0.035$. Minimum variance analysis of the electron velocity (MVA-$v_e$), MVA of $E$, minimization of Faraday residue, and an adjusted version of the maximum directional derivative of the magnetic field (MDD-$B$) technique all produce {reasonably} similar coordinate axes. We use virtual MMS data from a particle-in-cell simulation of this event to estimate the errors in the coordinate axes and reconnection rate associated with MVA-$v_e$ and MDD-$B$. The $L$ and $M$ directions are most reliably determined by MVA-$v_e$ when the spacecraft observes a clear electron jet reversal. When the magnetic field data has errors as small as 0.5\% of the background field strength, the $M$ direction obtained by MDD-$B$ technique may be off by as much as 35${}^{\circ }$. The normal direction is most accurately obtained by MDD-$B$. Overall, we find that these techniques were able to identify $E_M$ from the virtual data within error bars $\ge$20\%.

arXiv commentSubmitted to JGR - Space Physics

References in corpus (6)

• Electron-Scale Dynamics of the Diffusion Region during Symmetric Magnetic Reconnection in Space
• New Measure of the Dissipation Region in Collisionless Magnetic Reconnection
• Why does steady-state magnetic reconnection have a maximum local rate of order 0.1?
• Kinetic signatures of the region surrounding the X-line in asymmetric (magnetopause) reconnection
• Cassini in situ observations of long-duration magnetic reconnection in Saturn's magnetotail
• How Anomalous Resistivity Accelerates Magnetic Reconnection

Cited by in corpus (10)

• First-Principles Theory of the Rate of Magnetic Reconnection in Magnetospheric and Solar Plasmas
• Simulation of plasmaspheric plume impact on dayside magnetic reconnection
• Laboratory verification of electron-scale reconnection regions modulated by a three-dimensional instability
• Magnetic Flux Transport Identification of Active Reconnection: MMS Observations in Earth's Magnetosphere
• On the origin of "patchy" energy conversion in electron diffusion regions
• The muphyII Code: Multiphysics Plasma Simulation on Large HPC Systems
• An Energy Conserving Vlasov Solver That Tolerates Coarse Velocity Space Resolutions: Simulation of MMS Reconnection Events
• Fast Magnetic Reconnection induced by Resistivity Gradients in 2D Magnetohydrodynamics
• Energy partitioning between thermal and non-thermal electrons and ions in magnetotail reconnection
• Observational Evidence of Magnetic Reconnection in the Terrestrial Foreshock Region