Galactic Double Neutron Star total masses and Gaussian mixture model selection

Abstract

Huang et al. [arXiv:1804.03101] have analysed the population of 15 known galactic Double Neutron Stars (DNSs) regarding the total masses of these systems. They suggest the existence of two sub-populations, and report likelihood-based preference for a two-component Gaussian mixture model over a single Gaussian distribution. This note offers a cautionary perspective on model selection for this data set: Especially for such a small sample size, a pure likelihood ratio test can encourage overfitting. This can be avoided by penalising models with a higher number of free parameters. Re-examining the DNS total mass data set within the class of Gaussian mixture models, this can be achieved through several simple and well-established statistical tests, including information criteria (AICc, BIC), cross-validation, Bayesian evidence ratios and a penalised EM-test. While this re-analysis confirms the basic finding that a two-component mixture is consistent with the data, the model selection criteria consistently indicate that there is no robust preference for it over a single-component fit. Additional DNS discoveries will be needed to settle the question of sub-populations.

9 pages and 10 figures including appendices, updated version as accepted by MNRAS

References in corpus (13)

• GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
• GW170817: Measurements of Neutron Star Radii and Equation of State
• Constraining the Maximum Mass of Neutron Stars From Multi-Messenger Observations of GW170817
• Introduction to astroML: Machine Learning for Astrophysics
• Search for post-merger gravitational waves from the remnant of the binary neutron star merger GW170817
• Hypothesis test for normal mixture models: The EM approach
• Search for gravitational waves from a long-lived remnant of the binary neutron star merger GW170817
• The Spin Distribution of Fast Spinning Neutron Stars in Low Mass X-Ray Binaries: Evidence for Two Sub-Populations
• The binary pulsar PSR J1811-1736: evidence of a low amplitude supernova kick
• MeerTime - the MeerKAT Key Science Program on Pulsar Timing
• GW170817 and the prospect of forming supramassive remnants in neutron star mergers
• On GW170817 and the Galactic Binary Neutron Star Population
• Total gravitational mass of the Galactic Double Neutron Star systems: evidence for a bimodal distribution

Cited by in corpus (8)

• The mass distribution of Galactic double neutron stars
• Black holes in the low mass gap: Implications for gravitational wave observations
• Label Switching Problem in Bayesian Analysis for Gravitational Wave Astronomy
• Robust model comparison tests of DAMA/LIBRA annual modulation
• First observational evidence of a relation between globular clusters' internal rotation and stellar masses
• Classification of Pulsar Glitch Amplitudes using Extreme Deconvolution
• Neutron Star Merger Remnants: Braking Indices, Gravitational Waves, and the Equation Of State
• Classification of Pulsars using Extreme Deconvolution