Naturalness, Extra-Empirical Theory Assessments, and the Implications of Skepticism
arXiv:1806.07289 · doi:10.1007/s10701-018-0220-x
Abstract
Naturalness is an extra-empirical quality that aims to assess plausibility of a theory. Finetuning measures are often deputized to quantify the task. However, knowing statistical distributions on parameters appears necessary. Such meta-theories are not known yet. A critical discussion of these issues is presented, including their possible resolutions in fixed points. Both agreement to and skepticism of naturalness's utility remains credible, as is skepticism to any extra-empirical theory assessment (SEETA) that claims to identify "more correct" theories that are equally empirically adequate. The severe implications of SEETA are set forward in some detail. We conclude with a summary and discussion of the viability of three main viewpoints toward naturalness and fine-tuning, where the "moderate naturalness position" is suggested to be most appealing, not suffering from the disquietudes of the extreme pro- and anti-naturalness positions.
arXiv comment19 pages, 6 figures. summary conclusions added
References in corpus (15)
- Multi-TeV Scalars are Natural in Minimal Supergravity
- Focus Points and Naturalness in Supersymmetry
- Not Even Decoupling Can Save Minimal Supersymmetric SU(5)
- Superconducting Detectors for Super Light Dark Matter
- Detecting Superlight Dark Matter with Fermi-Degenerate Materials
- A Clockwork Theory
- Measures of fine tuning
- A modified naturalness principle and its experimental tests
- Naturalness and superpartner masses or when to give up on weak scale supersymmetry
- Higgs mass naturalness and scale invariance in the UV
- Clockwork / Linear Dilaton: Structure and Phenomenology
- Criteria for Natural Hierarchies
- Quantified naturalness from Bayesian statistics
- Naturalness, Conformal Symmetry and Duality
- Higgs naturalness and the scalar boson proliferation instability problem