Quantum fields during black hole formation: How good an approximation is the Unruh state?

Abstract

We study the quantum effects of a test Klein-Gordon field in a Vaidya spacetime consisting of a collapsing null shell that forms a Schwazschild black hole, by explicitly obtaining, in a $(1+1)$-dimensional model, the Wightman function, the renormalised stress-energy tensor, and by analysing particle detector rates along stationary orbits in the exterior black hole region, and make a comparison with the folklore that the Unruh state is the state that emerges from black hole formation. In the causal future of the shell, we find a negative ingoing flux at the horizon that agrees precisely with the Unruh state calculation, and is the source of black hole radiation, while in the future null infinity we find that the radiation flux output in the Unruh state is an upper bound for the positive outgoing flux in the collapsing null shell spacetime. This indicates that back-reaction estimates based on Unruh state calculations over-estimate the energy output carried by so-called pre-Hawking radiation. The value of the output predicted by the Unruh state is however approached exponentially fast. Finally, we find that at late times, stationary observers in the exterior black hole region in the collapsing shell spacetime detect the local Hawking temperature, which is also well characterised by the Unruh state, coming from right-movers. Early-time discrepancies between the detector rates for the Unruh state and for the state in the collapsing shell spacetime are explored numerically.

arXiv commentV2. 25 pages, 7 figures. Minor errors and typos fixed. Added references. Expanded discussion in Sec. 2.2 and 4.3

References in corpus (22)

• The generally covariant locality principle -- A new paradigm for local quantum physics
• On smooth Cauchy hypersurfaces and Geroch's splitting theorem
• Smoothness of time functions and the metric splitting of globally hyperbolic spacetimes
• A Self-consistent Model of the Black Hole Evaporation
• Algebraic QFT in Curved Spacetime and quasifree Hadamard states: an introduction
• Quantum Field Theory on Curved Backgrounds -- A Primer
• Onset and decay of the 1+1 Hawking-Unruh effect: what the derivative-coupling detector saw
• Mirror Reflections of a Black Hole
• Interior of Black Holes and Information Recovery
• Radiation from collapsing shells, semiclassical backreaction and black hole formation
• Slicing the Vacuum: New Accelerating Mirror Solutions of the Dynamical Casimir Effect
• Eternal and Evanescent Black Holes: It's All Done With Mirrors
• Phenomenological Description of the Interior of the Schwarzschild Black Hole
• Quantum Energy Inequalities and local covariance I: Globally hyperbolic spacetimes
• Role of evaporation in gravitational collapse
• Quantum energy inequalities and local covariance II: Categorical formulation
• Pre-Hawking radiation cannot prevent the formation of apparent horizon
• On the construction of Hartle-Hawking-Israel states across a static bifurcate Killing horizon
• Do event horizons exist?
• The information recovery problem
• Model for Quantum Effects in Stellar Collapse
• Horizon avoidance in spherically-symmetric collapse

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Phenomenological aspects of black holes beyond general relativity
• Harvesting Entanglement with Detectors Freely Falling into a Black Hole
• Harvesting correlations in Schwarzschild and collapsing shell spacetimes
• Channel capacity of relativistic quantum communication with rapid interaction
• Finite Energy but Infinite Entropy Production from Moving Mirrors
• Circular motion analogue Unruh effect in a $2+1$ thermal bath: Robbing from the rich and giving to the poor
• Entanglement harvesting from conformal vacuums between two Unruh-DeWitt detectors moving along null paths
• Unruh-DeWitt detector in dimensionally-reduced static spherically symmetric spacetimes
• Particle Detectors from Localized Quantum Field Theories
• Quantum correlations across the horizon in acoustic and gravitational Black Holes
• Non-perturbative simple-generated interactions with a quantum field for arbitrary Gaussian states
• Dissipative dynamics of an open quantum battery in the BTZ spacetime
• Unruh quantum Otto engine in the presence of a reflecting boundary
• Response of an Unruh-DeWitt detector near an extremal black hole
• Relativistic quantum information as radiation reaction: entanglement entropy and self-force of a moving mirror analog to the CGHS black hole
• Transmission of quantum information through quantum fields in curved spacetimes
• Derivative coupling in horizon brightened acceleration radiation: a quantum optics approach
• The Unruh vacuum and the in-vacuum in the Reissner-Nordström spacetime
• Hadamard states on spherically symmetric characteristic surfaces, the semi-classical Einstein equations and the Hawking effect
• Quantum strong cosmic censorship and black hole evaporation
• Closed-form expressions for smeared bi-distributions of a massless scalar field: non-perturbative and asymptotic results in relativistic quantum information
• Quenched entanglement harvesting
• Derivative coupling enables genuine entanglement harvesting in causal communication
• Are inertial vacua equivalent in Lorentz-violating theories? Does it matter?
• Locally detecting UV cutoffs on a sphere with particle detectors
• Particle detectors under chronological hazard
• Quantum kicks near a Cauchy horizon
• Black holes and their horizons in semiclassical and modified theories of gravity
• UV Effects and Short-Lived Hawking Radiation: Alternative Resolution of Information Paradox