The Radial Velocity Variability of the K-giant Gamma Draconis: Stellar Variability Masquerading as a Planet

Abstract

We present precise stellar radial velocity measurements of Gamma Dra taken from 2003 to 2017. The data from 2003 to 2011 show coherent, long-lived variations with a period of 702 d. These variations are consistent with the presence of a planetary companion having m sin i = 10.7 M_Jup whose orbital properties are typical for giant planets found around evolved stars. An analysis of the Hipparcos photometry, Ca II S-index measurements, and measurements of the spectral line shapes during this time show no variations with the radial velocity of the planet which seems to "confirm"' the presence of the planet. However, radial velocity measurements taken 2011 -- 2017 seem to refute this. From 2011 to 2013 the radial velocity variations virtually disappear only to return in 2014, but with a noticeable phase shift. The total radial velocity variations are consistent either with amplitude variations on timescales of ~ 10.6 yr, or the beating effect between two periods of 666 d and 801 d. It seems unlikely that both these signals stem from a two-planet system. A simple dynamical analysis indicates that there is only a 1-2 % chance that the two-planet is stable. Rather, we suggest that this multi-periodic behavior may represent a new form of stellar variability, possibly related to oscillatory convective modes. If such intrinsic stellar variability is common around K giant stars and is attributed to planetary companions, then the planet occurrence rate among these stars may be significantly lower than thought.

arXiv comment37 pages, 9 figures. Accepted for publication in The Astronomical Journal

References in corpus (25)

• Validation of the new Hipparcos reduction
• Evolutionary tracks and isochrones for low- and intermediate-mass stars: from 0.15 to 7 M_sun, and from Z=0.0004 to 0.03
• No planet for HD 166435
• Basic physical parameters of a selected sample of evolved stars
• Retired A Stars and Their Companions: Exoplanets Orbiting Three Intermediate-Mass Subgiants
• The atmospheric parameters and spectral interpolator for the stars of MILES
• Solar-like oscillations in eta Boo
• Planetary Companions around Three Intermediate-Mass G and K Giants: 18 Del, xi Aql, and HD 81688
• The Pan-Pacific Planet Search. I. A Giant Planet Orbiting 7 CMa
• Stellar population models in the UV: I. Characterisation of the New Generation Stellar Library
• Searching for Planets in the Hyades II: Some Implications of Stellar Magnetic Activity
• Radial Velocity Observations and Light Curve Noise Modeling Confirm That Kepler-91b is a Giant Planet Orbiting a Giant Star
• Study of the impact of the post-MS evolution of the host star on the orbits of close-in planets. I. Sample definition and physical properties
• Discovery of a planet around the K giant star 4 UMa
• Further evidence for the planet around 51 Pegasi
• A Planet in a 0.6-AU Orbit Around the K0 Giant HD 102272
• Rotation and Macroturbulence in Metal-poor Field Red Giant and Red Horizontal Branch Stars
• Bolometric correction and spectral energy distribution of cool stars in Galactic clusters
• Long-lived, long-period radial velocity variations in Aldebaran: A planetary companion and stellar activity
• Detection of a Planetary Companion around the giant star \gam1leo
• The Discovery of Stellar Oscillations in the K Giant $\iota$ Dra
• The conjectured S-type retrograde planet in nu Octantis: more evidence including four years of iodine-cell radial velocities
• Line-depth-ratio temperatures for the close binary nu Octantis: new evidence supporting the conjectured retrograde planet
• Detection of an exoplanet around the evolved K giant HD 66141
• The discovery of a planetary candidate around the evolved low-mass Kepler giant star HD 175370

Cited by in corpus (23)

• Precise radial velocities of giant stars XVI. Planet occurrence rates from the combined analysis of the Lick, EXPRESS, and PPPS giant star surveys
• Truly eccentric. I. Revisiting eight single-eccentric planetary systems
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars. X. Bayesian stellar parameters and evolutionary stages for 372 giant stars from the Lick planet search
• KELT-25b and KELT-26b: A Hot Jupiter and a Substellar Companion Transiting Young A-stars Observed by TESS
• Multi-band high resolution spectroscopy rules out the hot Jupiter BD+20 1790b - First data from the GIARPS Commissioning
• 37 New Validated Planets in Overlapping K2 Campaigns
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars. XII. Evidence against the proposed planet Aldebaran b
• A close-in giant planet escapes engulfment by its star
• A Gaussian Process Regression Reveals No Evidence for Planets Orbiting Kapteyn's Star
• Sub-stellar Companions of Intermediate-mass Stars with CoRoT: CoRoT-34b, CoRoT-35b, and CoRoT-36b
• Li-rich K giants, dust excess, and binarity
• Regular Radial Velocity Variations in Nine G- and K-type Giant Stars: Eight Planets and One Planet Candidate
• Planets around evolved intermediate-mass stars III. Planet candidates and long-term activity signals in six open clusters
• Pollux: A weak dynamo-driven dipolar magnetic field and implications for its probable planet
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars XV. Mysterious nearly periodic radial velocity variations in the eccentric binary $\epsilon$ Cygni
• A Search for Exoplanets around Northern Circumpolar Stars. IV. Six Planet Candidates to the K Giants, HD 44385, HD 97619, HD 106574, HD 118904, HD 164428, and HD 202432
• Non-radial oscillations mimicking a brown dwarf orbiting the cluster giant NGC 4349 No. 127
• A photospheric and chromospheric activity analysis of the quiescent retrograde-planet host $\nu$ Octantis A
• Tracking Advanced Planetary Systems (TAPAS) with HARPS-N VII. Elder suns with low-mass companions
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars -- XVII. Distinguishing planets from intrinsically induced radial velocity signals in evolved stars
• Search for Exoplanets around Northern Circumpolar Stars V. Three likely planetary companions to the giant stars HD 19615, HD 150010, and HD 174205
• Halo Photometry and Asteroseismology for 98 of the Brightest Stars Observed by TESS
• Asteroseismology of iota Draconis and Discovery of an Additional Long-Period Companion