The Trojan Color Conundrum

Abstract

The Trojan asteroids of Jupiter and Neptune are likely to have been captured from original heliocentric orbits in the dynamically excited ("hot") population of the Kuiper belt. However, it has long been known that the optical color distributions of the Jovian Trojans and the hot population are not alike. This difference has been reconciled with the capture hypothesis by assuming that the Trojans were resurfaced (for example, by sublimation of near-surface volatiles) upon inward migration from the Kuiper belt (where blackbody temperatures are $\sim$40 K) to Jupiter's orbit ($\sim$125 K). Here, we examine the optical color distribution of the \textit{Neptunian} Trojans using a combination of new optical photometry and published data. We find a color distribution that is statistically indistinguishable from that of the Jovian Trojans but unlike any sub-population in the Kuiper belt. This result is puzzling, because the Neptunian Trojans are very cold (blackbody temperature $\sim$50 K) and a thermal process acting to modify the surface colors at Neptune's distance would also affect the Kuiper belt objects beyond, where the temperatures are nearly identical. The distinctive color distributions of the Jovian and Neptunian Trojans thus present us with a conundrum: they are very similar to each other, suggesting either capture from a common source or surface modification by a common process. However, the color distributions differ from any plausible common source population, and there is no known modifying process that could operate equally at both Jupiter and Neptune.

The Astronomical Journal, in press; 3 figures, 4 tables

References in corpus (29)

• The Active Centaurs
• The Absolute Magnitude Distribution of Kuiper Belt Objects
• The colours of the Sun
• Colors and Spectra of Kuiper Belt Objects
• Population and Size Distribution of Small Jovian Trojan Asteroids
• Color Systematics of Comets and Related Bodies
• The albedo-color diversity of transneptunian objects
• WISE/NEOWISE Observations of the Jovian Trojan Population: Taxonomy
• The Kuiper Belt Luminosity Function from m(R)=21 to 26
• The Properties of Jovian Trojan Asteroids Listed in SDSS Moving Object Catalog 3
• Neptune Trojans as a Testbed for Planet Formation
• Colours of minor bodies in the outer solar system - II: A statistical analysis revisited
• The Bimodal Colors of Centaurs and Small Kuiper Belt Objects
• A hypothesis for the color bimodality of Jupiter Trojans
• A carefully characterised and tracked Trans-Neptunian survey, the size-distribution of the Plutinos and the number of Neptunian Trojans
• Reanalyzing the visible colors of Centaurs and KBOs: what is there and what we might be missing
• Origin and Dynamical Evolution of Neptune Trojans - I: Formation and Planetary Migration
• Transneptunian objects and Centaurs from light curves
• The Colors of Extreme Outer Solar System Objects
• The Color Differences of Kuiper Belt Objects in Resonance with Neptune
• The bimodal color distribution of small Kuiper Belt objects
• Survival of Trojan-Type Companions of Neptune During Primordial Planet Migration
• The Neptune Trojans - a new source for the Centaurs?
• Rotational properties of the binary and non-binary populations in the Trans-Neptunian belt
• Lightcurves of 32 Large Transneptunian Objects
• The Intrinsic Neptune Trojan Orbit Distribution: Implications for the Primordial Disk and Planet Migration
• The heart of the swarm: K2 photometry and rotational characteristics of 56 Jovian Trojan asteroids
• Small Jupiter Trojans Survey with Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam
• 2011 HM102: Discovery of a High-Inclination L5 Neptune Trojan in the Search for a post-Pluto New Horizons Target

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Kuiper belt: formation and evolution
• The origin of interstellar asteroidal objects like 1I/2017 U1 'Oumuamua
• The consequences of planetary migration on the minor bodies of the early Solar System
• OSSOS XX: The Meaning of Kuiper Belt Colors
• An interstellar origin for Jupiter's retrograde co-orbital asteroid
• Stability of Jovian Trojans and their collisional families
• Colors and Shapes of the Irregular Planetary Satellites
• Physical Characterization of the December 2017 Outburst of the Centaur 174P/Echeclus
• The Transient Jupiter Trojan-Like Orbit of P/2019 LD2 (ATLAS)
• Implications for the collisional strength of Jupiter Trojans from the Eurybates family
• Absolute colours and phase coefficients of trans-Neptunian objects: Correlations and Populations
• OSSOS: The Eccentricity and Inclination Distributions of the Stable Neptunian Trojans
• From Centaurs to comets - 40 years
• Keck, Gemini, and Palomar 200-inch visible photometry of red and very-red Neptunian Trojans
• The Case for a Large-Scale Occultation Network
• The Contribution of Dwarf Planets to the Origin of Low Inclination Comets by the Replenishment of Mean Motion Resonances in Debris Disks
• Colors of Irregular Satellites of Saturn with DECam
• Evidence for Color Dichotomy in the Primordial Neptunian Trojan Population
• Causal evidence for the primordiality of colours in trans-Neptunian objects