A cautionary tale of interpreting O-C diagrams: period instability in a classical RR Lyr Star Z CVn mimicking as a distant companion

Abstract

We present a comprehensive study of Z CVn, an RR Lyrae star that shows long-term cyclic variations of its pulsation period. A possible explanation suggested from the shape of the O-C diagram is the light travel-time effect, which we thoroughly examine. We used original photometric and spectroscopic measurements and investigated the period evolution using available maximum times spanning more than one century. If the binary hypothesis is valid, Z CVn orbits around a black hole with minimal mass of $56.5$ ${\mathfrak{M}}_{\odot }$ on a very wide ($P_{\mathrm{orbit}}=78.3$ years) and eccentric orbit ($e=0.63$). We discuss the probability of a formation of a black hole-RR Lyrae pair and, although we found it possible, there is no observational evidence of the black hole in the direction to Z CVn. However, the main objection against the binary hypothesis is the comparison of the systemic radial velocity curve model and spectroscopic observations that clearly show that Z CVn cannot be bound in such a binary. Therefore, the variations of pulsation period are likely intrinsic to the star. This finding represents a discovery/confirmation of a new type of cyclic period changes in RR Lyrae stars. By the analysis of our photometric data, we found that the Blazhko modulation with period of 22.931 d is strongly dominant in amplitude. The strength of the phase modulation varies and is currently almost undetectable. We also estimated photometric physical parameters of Z CVn and investigated their variations during the Blazhko cycle using the Inverse Baade-Wesselink method.

arXiv comment15 pages, 8 tables, 9 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (48)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• The WASP Project and the SuperWASP Cameras
• The Fourth US Naval Observatory CCD Astrograph Catalog (UCAC4)
• Properties of the Binary Black Hole Merger GW150914
• The first gravitational-wave source from the isolated evolution of two 40-100 Msun stars
• The Black Hole Mass Distribution in the Galaxy
• Empirical Color Transformations Between SDSS Photometry and Other Photometric Systems
• Mass Limits For Black Hole Formation
• Northern Sky Variability Survey (NSVS): Public data release
• The first WASP public data release
• Metal Abundances, Radial Velocities and other Physical Characteristics for the RR Lyrae Stars in the Kepler Field
• RR-Lyrae-type pulsations from a 0.26-solar-mass star in a binary system
• The Konkoly Blazhko Survey: Is light-curve modulation a common property of RRab stars?
• Magnetic massive stars as progenitors of "heavy" stellar-mass black holes
• Stellar evolution through the ages: period variations in galactic RRab stars as derived from the GEOS database and TAROT telescopes
• Evidence for an Overluminosity of the Variable Star RR Lyr, and a Revised Distance to the LMC
• Blazhko RR Lyrae light curves as modulated signals
• On the evolutionary and pulsation mass of Classical Cepheids: III. the case of the eclipsing binary Cepheid CEP0227 in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The Metallicity Dependence of the Fourier Components of RR Lyrae Light Curves is the Oosterhoff/Arp/Preston Period Ratio Effect in Disguise
• New RR Lyrae variables in binary systems
• The occurrence of Binary Evolution Pulsators in the classical instability strip of RR Lyrae and Cepheid variables
• Template RR Lyrae H alpha, H beta, and H gamma Velocity Curves
• Pulsation models for the 0.26M_sun star mimicking RR Lyrae pulsator. Model survey for the new class of variable stars
• The Changing Blazhko Effect of XZ Cygni
• Long-term photometric monitoring of RR Lyr stars in M3
• Period changes in omega Centauri RR Lyrae stars
• Cyclic variations in O-C diagrams of field RR Lyrae stars as a result of LiTE
• An extensive photometric study of the Blazhko RR Lyrae star MW Lyr: II. Changes in the physical parameters
• Orbital and physical parameters of eclipsing binaries from the ASAS catalogue -- I. A sample of systems with components' masses between 1 and 2 M${}_{\odot }$
• The Multi-periodic Blazhko Modulation of CZ Lacertae
• An extensive photometric study of the Blazhko RR Lyrae star DM Cyg
• Long-term photometric monitoring of Messier 5 variables: I. Period changes of RR Lyrae stars
• New analysis of the light time effect in TU Ursae Majoris
• The all-sky GEOS RR Lyr survey with the TAROT telescopes. Analysis of the Blazhko effect
• Period Change Similarities among the RR Lyrae Variables in Oosterhoff I and Oosterhoff II Globular Systems
• KIC 2831097 - A 2-year orbital-period RR Lyrae binary candidate
• RR Lyrae stars: Kinematics, orbits and z-distribution
• The Blazhko behaviour of RR Geminorum II -- long-term photometric results
• A first-overtone RR Lyrae star with cyclic period changes
• A new method for determining physical parameters of fundamental mode RR Lyrae stars from multicolour light curves
• KIC 11401845: An Eclipsing Binary with Multiperiodic Pulsations and Light Travel Time
• An extensive photometric study of the Blazhko RR Lyrae star RZ Lyr
• The light-curve modulation of XY And and UZ Vir - Two Blazhko RR Lyrae stars with additional frequencies
• Masses of the components of SB2 binaries observed with Gaia. III. Accurate SB2 orbits for 10 binaries and masses of HIP 87895
• Pulsating Components in Binary and Multiple Stellar Systems --- A Catalog of Oscillating Binaries
• A New Overview of Secular Period Changes of RR Lyrae stars inM5
• The OGLE Collection of Variable Stars. Over 45 000 RR Lyrae Stars in the Magellanic System

Cited by in corpus (9)

• First results on RR Lyrae stars with the TESS space telescope: untangling the connections between mode content, colors and distances
• Studies of RR Lyrae Variables in Binary Systems. I.: Evidence of a Trimodal Companion Mass Distribution
• Candidates for RR~Lyrae in binary systems from the OGLE Galactic bulge survey
• A Radial Velocity Search for Binary RR Lyrae Variables
• Time series analysis of bright TESS RRc stars: Additional modes, phase variations and more
• Reanalysis of c-type RR Lyrae Variable BE Dor, Period Modulations and Possible Mechanism
• RR Lyrae Stars in Intermediate-age Magellanic Clusters: Membership Probabilities and Delay Time Distribution
• The elusive chase for the first RR Lyr star in a binary system: the case of KIC 2831097
• Synergy between professional and amateur astronomers