Performance Comparison of Intrusion Detection Systems and Application of Machine Learning to Snort System

Abstract

This study investigates the performance of two open source intrusion detection systems (IDSs) namely Snort and Suricata for accurately detecting the malicious traffic on computer networks. Snort and Suricata were installed on two different but identical computers and the performance was evaluated at 10 Gbps network speed. It was noted that Suricata could process a higher speed of network traffic than Snort with lower packet drop rate but it consumed higher computational resources. Snort had higher detection accuracy and was thus selected for further experiments. It was observed that the Snort triggered a high rate of false positive alarms. To solve this problem a Snort adaptive plug-in was developed. To select the best performing algorithm for Snort adaptive plug-in, an empirical study was carried out with different learning algorithms and Support Vector Machine (SVM) was selected. A hybrid version of SVM and Fuzzy logic produced a better detection accuracy. But the best result was achieved using an optimised SVM with firefly algorithm with FPR (false positive rate) as 8.6% and FNR (false negative rate) as 2.2%, which is a good result. The novelty of this work is the performance comparison of two IDSs at 10 Gbps and the application of hybrid and optimised machine learning algorithms to Snort.

25 pages

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Privacy and Trust Redefined in Federated Machine Learning
• Dynamic and Application-Aware Provisioning of Chained Virtual Security Network Functions
• MBTree: Detecting Encryption RAT Communication Using Malicious Behavior Tree
• Malware Squid: A Novel IoT Malware Traffic Analysis Framework using Convolutional Neural Network and Binary Visualisation
• A machine-learning approach to Detect users' suspicious behaviour through the Facebook wall
• Network Intrusion Detection based on LSTM and Feature Embedding
• Intrusion Detection Systems for Smart Home IoT Devices: Experimental Comparison Study
• Hybrid-Generative Diffusion Models for Attack-Oriented Twin Migration in Vehicular Metaverses
• Comprehensive Botnet Detection by Mitigating Adversarial Attacks, Navigating the Subtleties of Perturbation Distances and Fortifying Predictions with Conformal Layers
• Beyond the Hype: A Real-World Evaluation of the Impact and Cost of Machine Learning-Based Malware Detection
• Evaluation of Network Based IDS and Deployment of multi-sensor IDS