Energy-based comparison between the Fourier--Galerkin method and the finite element method
arXiv:1709.08477 · doi:10.1016/j.cam.2019.112585
Abstract
The Fourier-Galerkin method (in short FFTH) has gained popularity in numerical homogenisation because it can treat problems with a huge number of degrees of freedom. Because the method incorporates the fast Fourier transform (FFT) in the linear solver, it is believed to provide an improvement in computational and memory requirements compared to the conventional finite element method (FEM). Here, we systematically compare these two methods using the energetic norm of local fields, which has the clear physical interpretation as being the error in the homogenised properties. This enables the comparison of memory and computational requirements at the same level of approximation accuracy. We show that the methods' effectiveness relies on the smoothness (regularity) of the solution and thus on the material coefficients. Thanks to its approximation properties, FEM outperforms FFTH for problems with jumps in material coefficients, while ambivalent results are observed for the case that the material coefficients vary continuously in space. FFTH profits from a good conditioning of the linear system, independent of the number of degrees of freedom, but generally needs more degrees of freedom to reach the same approximation accuracy. More studies are needed for other FFT-based schemes, non-linear problems, and dual problems (which require special treatment in FEM but not in FFTH).
arXiv comment24 pages, 10 figures, 2 tables
References in corpus (15)
- Generalized Multiscale Finite Element Methods (GMsFEM)
- Fourier-based schemes for computing the mechanical response of composites with accurate local fields
- Accelerating a FFT-based solver for numerical homogenization of periodic media by conjugate gradients
- An FFT-based Galerkin Method for Homogenization of Periodic Media
- Fourier-based schemes with modified Green operator for computing the electrical response of heterogeneous media with accurate local fields
- Finite strain FFT-based non-linear solvers made simple
- A finite element perspective on non-linear FFT-based micromechanical simulations
- How collective asperity detachments nucleate slip at frictional interfaces
- Guaranteed upper-lower bounds on homogenized properties by FFT-based Galerkin method
- A comparative study on low-memory iterative solvers for FFT-based homogenization of periodic media
- Improved guaranteed computable bounds on homogenized properties of periodic media by Fourier-Galerkin method with exact integration
- Fracture initiation in multi-phase materials: a statistical characterization of microstructural damage sites
- Microstructural modeling of ductile fracture initiation in multi-phase materials
- Analysis of a Fast Fourier Transform Based Method for Modeling of Heterogeneous Materials
- Double-grid quadrature with interpolation-projection (DoGIP) as a novel discretisation approach: An application to FEM on simplexes