Quantifying Confidence in Density Functional Theory Predicted Magnetic Ground States

Abstract

The success of descriptor-based material design relies on eliminating bad candidates and keeping good candidates for further investigation. While DFT has been widely successfully for the former, often times good candidates are lost due to the uncertainty associated with the DFT-predicted material properties. Uncertainty associated with DFT predictions has gained prominence and has led to the development of exchange correlation functionals that have built-in error estimation capability. In this work, we demonstrate the use of built-in error estimation capabilities within the BEEF-vdW exchange correlation functional for quantifying the uncertainty associated with the magnetic ground state of solids. We demonstrate this approach by calculating the uncertainty estimate for the energy difference between the different magnetic states of solids and compare them against a range of GGA exchange correlation functionals as is done in many first principles calculations of materials. We show that this estimate reasonably bounds the range of values obtained with the different GGA functionals. The estimate is determined as a post-processing step and thus provides a computationally robust and systematic approach to estimating uncertainty associated with predictions of magnetic ground states. We define a confidence value (c-value) that incorporates all calculated magnetic states in order to quantify the concurrence of the prediction at the GGA level and argue that predictions of magnetic ground states from GGA level DFT is incomplete without an accompanying c-value. We demonstrate the utility of this method using a case study of Li and Na-ion cathode materials and the c-value metric correctly identifies that GGA level DFT will have low predictability for NaFePO${}_4$F.

8 pages, 2 figures

References in corpus (10)

• Restoring the density-gradient expansion for exchange in solids and surfaces
• Generalized gradient approximation for solids and their surfaces
• Spin current and magneto-electric effect in non-collinear magnets
• A real-space grid implementation of the Projector Augmented Wave method
• First principles study of the multiferroics BiFeO${}_3$, Bi${}_2$FeCrO${}_6$, and BiCrO${}_3$: Structure, polarization, and magnetic ordering temperature
• Crystal and magnetic structure of LaTiO3 : evidence for non-degenerate $t_{2g}$-orbitals
• High-Dimensional Materials and Process Optimization using Data-driven Experimental Design with Well-Calibrated Uncertainty Estimates
• Spin-induced symmetry breaking in orbitally ordered NiCr_2O_4 and CuCr_2O_4
• CaCrO3: an anomalous antiferromagnetic metallic oxide
• Quantification of uncertainty in first-principles predicted mechanical properties of solids: Application to solid ion conductors

Cited by in corpus (14)

• Quantifying Confidence in DFT Predicted Surface Pourbaix Diagrams and Associated Reaction Pathways for Chlorine Evolution
• Quantifying Confidence in DFT Predicted Surface Pourbaix Diagrams of Transition Metal Electrode-Electrolyte Interfaces
• Maximal predictability approach for identifying the right descriptors for electrocatalytic reactions
• The long road to calibrated prediction uncertainty in computational chemistry
• Robust high-fidelity DFT study of the lithium-graphite phase diagram
• Uncertainty Quantification of DFT-predicted Finite Temperature Thermodynamic Properties within the Debye Model
• ${\mathcal{P}}^2$: Combining pressure and electrochemistry to synthesize superhydrides
• Machine Learning Enabled Discovery of Application Dependent Design Principles for Two-dimensional Materials
• Uncertainty Quantification in First-Principles Predictions of Harmonic Vibrational Frequencies of Molecules and Molecular Complexes
• Uncertainty quantification in first-principles predictions of phonon properties and lattice thermal conductivity
• Towards Ultra Low Cobalt Cathodes: A High Fidelity Computational Phase Search of Layered Li-Ni-Mn-Co Oxides
• Theoretical Characterization of Structural Disorder in the Tetramer Model Structure of Eumelanin
• Reducing Self-Interaction Error in Transition-Metal Oxides with Different Exact-Exchange Fractions for Energy and Density
• A New Workflow for Materials Discovery Bridging the Gap Between Experimental Databases and Graph Neural Networks