A Critical Comparison of Lagrangian Methods for Coherent Structure Detection

Abstract

We review and test twelve different approaches to the detection of finite-time coherent material structures in two-dimensional, temporally aperiodic flows. We consider both mathematical methods and diagnostic scalar fields, comparing their performance on three benchmark examples: the quasiperiodically forced Bickley jet, a two-dimensional turbulence simulation, and an observational wind velocity field from Jupiter's atmosphere. A close inspection of the results reveals that the various methods often produce very different predictions for coherent structures, once they are evaluated beyond heuristic visual assessment. As we find by passive advection of the coherent set candidates, false positives and negatives can be produced even by some of the mathematically justified methods due to the ineffectiveness of their underlying coherence principles in certain flow configurations. We summarize the inferred strengths and weaknesses of each method, and make general recommendations for minimal self-consistency requirements that any Lagrangian coherence detection technique should satisfy.

References in corpus (31)

• Predictability in the large: an extension of the concept of Lyapunov exponent
• Mixing structures in the Mediterranean Sea from Finite-Size Lyapunov Exponents
• Defining Coherent Vortices Objectively from the Vorticity
• Dispersion of passive tracers in closed basins: beyond the diffusion coefficient
• Lagrangian Descriptors: A Method for Revealing Phase Space Structures of General Time Dependent Dynamical Systems
• Transport in time-dependent dynamical systems: Finite-time coherent sets
• Coherent Lagrangian vortices: The black holes of turbulence
• A Spectral Clustering Approach to Lagrangian Vortex Detection
• An analytic framework for identifying finite-time coherent sets in time-dependent dynamical systems
• Coherent sets for nonautonomous dynamical systems
• Understanding the geometry of transport: diffusion maps for Lagrangian trajectory data unravel coherent sets
• Tracing the early development of harmful algal blooms with the aid of Lagrangian coherent structures
• Hyperbolic and Elliptic Transport Barriers in Three-Dimensional Unsteady Flows
• Shearless transport barriers in unsteady two-dimensional flows and maps
• Dynamic isoperimetry and the geometry of Lagrangian coherent structures
• Attracting and repelling Lagrangian coherent structures from a single computation
• Do Finite-Size Lyapunov Exponents Detect Coherent Structures?
• Zonal Jets as Transport Barriers in Planetary Atmospheres
• Automated detection of coherent Lagrangian vortices in two-dimensional unsteady flows
• Polar rotation angle identifies elliptic islands in unsteady dynamical systems
• A dynamic Laplacian for identifying Lagrangian coherent structures on weighted Riemannian manifolds
• Geodesic Transport Barriers in Jupiter's Atmosphere: A Video-Based Analysis
• Characterization of coherent structures in three-dimensional flows using the finite-size Lyapunov exponent
• On fast computation of finite-time coherent sets using radial basis functions
• A Geometric Heat-Flow Theory of Lagrangian Coherent Structures
• Relatively Coherent Sets as a Hierarchical Partition Method
• Efficient Computation of Null-Geodesic with Applications to Coherent Vortex Detection
• Level set formulation of two-dimensional Lagrangian vortex detection methods
• Shape Coherence and Finite-Time Curvature Evolution
• An Autonomous Dynamical System Captures all LCSs in Three-Dimensional Unsteady Flows
• Performance of Lagrangian Descriptors and their variants in incompressible flows

Cited by in corpus (49)

• Material Barriers to Diffusive and Stochastic Transport
• Search and rescue at sea aided by hidden flow structures
• Confronting Grand Challenges in Environmental Fluid Mechanics
• Quantitative analysis of the kinematics and induced aerodynamic loading of individual vortices in vortex-dominated flows: a computation and data-driven approach
• Reproducing kernel Hilbert space compactification of unitary evolution groups
• Recent Advances in Computational Modeling of Thrombosis
• Sparse eigenbasis approximation: multiple feature extraction across spatiotemporal scales with application to coherent set identification
• Kinetic energy of eddy-like features from sea surface altimetry
• Probing turbulent superstructures in Rayleigh-Bénard convection by Lagrangian trajectory clusters
• Clustering of marine-debris- and \emph{Sargassum}-like drifters explained by inertial particle dynamics}
• Material and debris transport patterns in Moreton Bay, Australia: The influence of Lagrangian coherent structures
• Finite-time Lyapunov exponents in the instantaneous limit and material transport
• Lagrangian network analysis of turbulent mixing
• Solar Vortex Tubes: Vortex Dynamics in the Solar Atmosphere
• Detecting Lagrangian coherent structures from sparse and noisy trajectory data
• Supergranular turbulence in a quiet Sun: Lagrangian coherent structures
• Objective barriers to the transport of dynamically active vector fields
• Global dynamics visualisation from Lagrangian Descriptors. Applications to discrete and continuous systems
• A Geometric Heat-Flow Theory of Lagrangian Coherent Structures
• Quasi-Objective Coherent Structure Diagnostics from Single Trajectories
• Barriers to the Transport of Diffusive Scalars in Compressible Flows
• Evolutionary clustering of Lagrangian trajectories in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection flows
• Lagrangian heat transport in turbulent three-dimensional convection
• Local Causal States and Discrete Coherent Structures
• Role of Coherent Eddies in Potential Vorticity Transport in Two-layer Quasigeostrophic Turbulence
• The edge as a Lagrangian Coherent Structure in a high-dimensional state space
• Trajectory-free approximation of phase space structures using the trajectory divergence rate
• Exploratory Lagrangian-Based Particle Tracing Using Deep Learning
• Tracking areas with increased likelihood of surface particle aggregation in the Gulf of Finland: A first look at persistent Lagrangian Coherent Structures (LCS)
• Quasi-Objective Eddy Visualization from Sparse Drifter Data
• Identification of individual coherent sets associated with flow trajectories using Coherent Structure Coloring
• Network Measures of Mixing
• Lagrangian coherent sets in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection
• Simultaneous Coherent Structure Coloring facilitates interpretable clustering of scientific data by amplifying dissimilarity
• Finding regions of bounded motion in binary asteroid environment using Lagrangian descriptors
• Transfer Operators from Optimal Transport Plans for Coherent Set Detection
• Crossroads of the mesoscale circulation
• Identifying Reaction Pathways in Phase Space via Asymptotic Trajectories
• Using braids to quantify interface growth and coherence in a rotor-oscillator flow
• Lagrangian studies of coherent sets and heat transport in constant heat flux-driven turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection
• Relative Fluid Stretching and Rotation for Sparse Trajectory Observations
• Lyapunov exponents and Lagrangian chaos suppression in compressible homogeneous isotropic turbulence
• Towards Unsupervised Segmentation of Extreme Weather Events
• Coherent structure detection and the inverse cascade mechanism in two-dimensional Navier-Stokes turbulence
• Relevance of the Basset history term for Lagrangian particle dynamics
• A Voronoi-tessellation-based approach for detection of coherent structures in sparsely-seeded flows
• Defect-mediated dynamics of coherent structures in active nematics
• Sensitivity and robustness of Lagrangian coherent structures in coastal water systems
• The convergence of stochastic differential equations to their linearisation in small noise limits