Comment on: Observation of the Wigner-Huntington transition to metallic hydrogen

Abstract

In a recently published article [1], Ranga P. Dias & Isaac F. Silvera have reported the visual evidence of metallic hydrogen concomitantly with its characterization at a pressure of 495 GPa and low temperatures. We have expressed serious doubts of such a conclusion when interviewed to comment on this publication [2,3]. In the following comment, we would like to detail the reasons, based on experimental evidences obtained by us and by other groups worldwide that sustain our skepticism. We have identified two main flaws in this paper, as discussed in details below: the pressure is largely overestimated; the origin of the sample reflectivity and the analysis of the reflectance can be seriously questioned.

arXiv comment6 pages, 3 figures

Cited by in corpus (6)

• High-Temperature Superconductivity in Alkaline and Rare Earth Polyhydrides at High Pressure: A Theoretical Perspective
• Comment on "Observation of the Wigner-Huntington transition to metallic hydrogen"
• Strong electron-phonon and band structure effects in the optical properties of high pressure metallic hydrogen
• Electron localization properties in high pressure hydrogen at the liquid-liquid phase transition by Coupled Electron-Ion Monte Carlo
• Semimetallic molecular hydrogen at pressure above 350 GPa
• Comment on: Observation of a first order phase transition to metal hydrogen near 425 GPa