Density Functional Theory is Not Straying from the Path toward the Exact Functional

Abstract

Recently (Science, 355, 6320, 2017, 49-52) it was argued that density functionals stray from the path towards exactness due to errors in densities (ρ) of 14 atoms and ions computed with several recent functionals. However, this conclusion rests on very compact ρ of highly charged 1s2 and 1s22s2 systems, the divergence is due to one particular group's recently developed functionals, whereas other recent functionals perform well, and errors in ρ were not compared to actual energies E[ρ] of the same distinct, compact systems, but to general errors for diverse systems. As argued here, a true path can only be defined for E[ρ] and ρ for the same systems: By computing errors in E[ρ], it is shown that different functionals show remarkably linear error relationships between ρ and E[ρ] on well-defined but different paths towards exactness, and the ranking in Science, 355, 6320, 2017, 49-52 breaks down. For example, M06-2X, said to perform poorly, performs very well on the E,ρ paths defined here, and local (non-GGA) functionals rapidly increase errors in E[ρ] due to the failure to describe dynamic correlation of compact systems without the gradient. Finally, a measure of "exactness" is given by the product of errors in E[ρ] and ρ; these relationships may be more relevant focus points than a time line if one wants to estimate exactness and develop new exact functionals.

1 figure (Figure 1A, 1B, 1C) and two tables of supplementary data

Cited by in corpus (17)

• How accurate is density functional theory at predicting dipole moments? An assessment using a new database of 200 benchmark values
• Quantifying Density Errors in DFT
• Thermodynamics and its Prediction and CALPHAD Modeling: Review, State of the Art, and Perspectives
• Neural-network Kohn-Sham exchange-correlation potential and its out-of-training transferability
• A review on non-relativistic fully numerical electronic structure calculations on atoms and diatomic molecules
• ACCDB: A Collection of Chemistry DataBases for Broad Computational Purposes
• Enabling Large-Scale Condensed-Phase Hybrid Density Functional Theory Based $Ab$ $Initio$ Molecular Dynamics II: Extensions to the Isobaric-Isoenthalpic and Isobaric-Isothermal Ensembles
• The QUEST Database of Highly-Accurate Excitation Energies
• Too big, too small or just right? A benchmark assessment of density functional theory for predicting the spatial extent of the electron density of small chemical systems
• Improvement of functionals in density functional theory by the inverse Kohn--Sham method and density functional perturbation theory
• How good are recent density functionals for ground and excited states of one-electron systems?
• Ab initio construction of the energy density functional for electron systems with the functional-renormalization-group-aided density functional theory
• High-Throughput Condensed-Phase Hybrid Density Functional Theory for Large-Scale Finite-Gap Systems: The SeA Approach
• A simple and efficient route towards improved energetics within the framework of density-corrected density functional theory
• Using Electronegativity and Hardness to Test Density Functional Universality
• Engineering analog quantum chemistry Hamiltonians using cold atoms in optical lattices
• Quantum-Enhanced Neural Exchange-Correlation Functionals