A comment on "A test of general relativity using the LARES and LAGEOS satellites and a GRACE Earth gravity model", by I. Ciufolini et al

Abstract

Recently, Ciufolini et al. reported on a test of the general relativistic gravitomagnetic Lense-Thirring effect by analyzing about 3.5 years of laser ranging data to the LAGEOS, LAGEOS II, LARES geodetic satellites orbiting the Earth. By using the GRACE-based GGM05S Earth's global gravity model and a linear combination of the nodes $\Omega$ of the three satellites designed to remove the impact of errors in the first two even zonal harmonic coefficients $J_2,J_4$ of the multipolar expansion of the Newtonian part of the Earth's gravitational potential, they claimed an overall accuracy of $5\%$ for the Lense-Thirring caused node motion. We show that the scatter in the nominal values of the uncancelled even zonals of degree $\ell =6,8,10$ from some of the most recent global gravity models does not yet allow to reach unambiguously and univocally the expected $\approx 1\%$ level, being large up to $\lesssim 15\%(\ell =6),6\%(\ell =8),36\%(\ell =10)$ for some pairs of models.

arXiv commentLaTeX2e, 14 pages, 9 tables, no figures. The European Physical Journal C, at press

References in corpus (6)

• Phenomenology of the Lense-Thirring effect in the Solar System
• Testing General Relativity and gravitational physics using the LARES satellite
• A Test of General Relativity Using the LARES and LAGEOS Satellites and a GRACE Earth's Gravity Model
• The impact of the static part of the Earth's gravity field on some tests of General Relativity with Satellite Laser Ranging
• Fundamental Physics and General Relativity with the LARES and LAGEOS satellites
• The impact of the new Earth gravity models on the measurement of the Lense-Thirring effect with a new satellite

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Unleashing the full power of LHCb to probe Stealth New Physics
• Test of gravitomagnetism with satellites around the Earth
• Velocity-dependent inverse cubic force and solar system gravity tests
• "Reply to A comment on A test of general relativity using the LARES and LAGEOS satellites and a GRACE Earth gravity model, by I. Ciufolini et al."
• Measuring general relativistic dragging effects in the Earth's gravitational field with ELXIS: a proposal
• A New Set of Maxwell-Lorentz Equations and Rediscovery of Heaviside-Maxwellian (Vector) Gravity from Quantum Field Theory
• Frame-dragging: meaning, myths, and misconceptions