A closer look at the "characteristic" width of molecular cloud filaments

Abstract

Filaments in Herschel molecular cloud images are found to exhibit a "characteristic width". This finding is in tension with spatial power spectra of the data, which show no indication of this characteristic scale. We demonstrate that this discrepancy is a result of the methodology adopted for measuring filament widths. First, we perform the previously used analysis technique on artificial scale-free data, and obtain a peaked width distribution of filament-like structures. Next, we repeat the analysis on three Herschel maps and reproduce the narrow distribution of widths found in previous studies $-$ when considering the average width of each filament. However, the distribution of widths measured at all points along a filament spine is broader than the distribution of mean filament widths, indicating that the narrow spread (interpreted as a "characteristic" width) results from averaging. Furthermore, the width is found to vary significantly from one end of a filament to the other. Therefore, the previously identified peak at 0.1 pc cannot be understood as representing the typical width of filaments. We find an alternative explanation by modelling the observed width distribution as a truncated power-law distribution, sampled with uncertainties. The position of the peak is connected to the lower truncation scale and is likely set by the choice of parameters used in measuring filament widths. We conclude that a "characteristic" width of filaments is not supported by the available data.

arXiv comment15 pages (incl. appendices), 16 figures, accepted to MNRAS

References in corpus (37)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• emcee: The MCMC Hammer
• From filamentary clouds to prestellar cores to the stellar IMF: Initial highlights from the Herschel Gould Belt survey
• Interstellar Turbulence I: Observations and Processes
• Characterizing interstellar filaments with Herschel in IC5146
• The persistent cosmic web and its filamentary structure I: Theory and implementation
• Planck intermediate results. XXXV. Probing the role of the magnetic field in the formation of structure in molecular clouds
• Cores, filaments, and bundles: hierarchical core formation in the L1495/B213 Taurus region
• Flows, Fragmentation, and Star Formation. I. Low-mass Stars in Taurus
• On the universality of interstellar filaments: theory meets simulations and observations
• A census of dense cores in the Aquila cloud complex: SPIRE/PACS observations from the Herschel Gould Belt survey
• Herschel-SPIRE observations of the Polaris flare : structure of the diffuse interstellar medium at the sub-parsec scale
• On the nature of star-forming filaments: I. Filament morphologies
• On the origin of non self-gravitating filaments in the ISM
• Galactic cold cores III. General cloud properties
• CARMA Large Area Star Formation Survey: Observational Analysis of Filaments in the Serpens South Molecular Cloud
• Two Mass Distributions in the L 1641 Molecular Clouds: The Herschel connection of Dense Cores and Filaments in Orion A
• Gravitational Infall onto Molecular Filaments
• A Herschel study of the properties of starless cores in the Polaris Flare dark cloud region using PACS and SPIRE
• Characterizing filaments in regions of high-mass star formation: High-resolution submilimeter imaging of the massive star-forming complex NGC 6334 with ArTéMiS
• Ion-neutral friction and accretion-driven turbulence in self-gravitating filaments
• Profiling filaments: comparing near-infrared extinction and submillimetre data in TMC-1
• Herschel's view of the large-scale structure in the Chamaeleon dark clouds
• Probing interstellar turbulence in cirrus with deep optical imaging: no sign of energy dissipation at 0.01 pc scale
• Investigating the structure and fragmentation of a highly filamentary IRDC
• Unveiling the Early-Stage Anatomy of a Protocluster Hub with ALMA
• ${}^{13}\mathrm{CO}$ Filaments in the Taurus Molecular Cloud
• The magnetic field and dust filaments in the Polaris Flare
• Filaments in the Lupus molecular clouds
• Collective outflow from a small multiple stellar system
• The effect of ambipolar diffusion on low-density molecular ISM filaments
• Small-area molecular clouds without shielding
• A Magnetic Ribbon Model for Star-Forming Filaments
• Characterizing the Turbulent Properties of the Starless Molecular Cloud MBM16
• The Star Formation Law in a Multifractal ISM
• Estimating distance, pressure, and dust opacity using submillimeter observations of self-gravitating filaments
• Herschel dust emission as a probe of starless cores mass: MCLD 123.5+24.9 of the Polaris Flare

Cited by in corpus (58)

• An ALMA study of the Orion Integral Filament: I. Evidence for narrow fibers in a massive cloud
• Characterizing the properties of nearby molecular filaments observed with Herschel
• COSMOS2015 photometric redshifts probe the impact of filaments on galaxy properties
• The Green Bank Ammonia Survey (GAS): First Results of NH3 mapping the Gould Belt
• Gravity drives the evolution of infrared dark hubs: JVLA observations of SDC13
• Dynamics of cluster-forming hub-filament systems: The case of the high-mass star-forming complex Monoceros R2
• Filamentary Accretion Flows in the Infrared Dark Cloud G14.225-0.506 Revealed by ALMA
• On the Three-Dimensional Structure of Local Molecular Clouds
• A holistic perspective on the dynamics of G035.39-00.33: the interplay between gas and magnetic fields
• From diffuse gas to dense molecular cloud cores
• The CARMA-NRO Orion Survey: The filamentary structure as seen in C${}^{18}$O emission
• How do stars gain their mass? A JCMT/SCUBA-2 Transient Survey of Protostars in Nearby Star Forming Regions
• Interstellar filaments and star formation
• Morphology and Kinematics of Filaments in the Serpens and Perseus Molecular Clouds
• Zooming in on Individual Star Formation: Low- and High-mass Stars
• The Self-gravitating Gas Fraction and The Critical Density for Star Formation
• Dense gas kinematics and a narrow filament in the Orion A OMC1 region using NH3
• RadFil: a Python Package for Building and Fitting Radial Profiles for Interstellar Filaments
• Formation of the Musca filament: Evidence for asymmetries in the accretion flow due to a cloud-cloud collision
• Magnetized interstellar molecular clouds: II. The Large-Scale Structure and Dynamics of Filamentary Molecular Clouds
• The width of Herschel filaments varies with distance
• A dynamically young, gravitationally stable network of filaments in Orion B
• L1495 Revisited: A PPMAP View of a Star-Forming Filament
• Probing the cold magnetized Universe with SPICA-POL (B-BOP)
• The structure and characteristic scales of molecular clouds
• Measuring the filamentary structure of interstellar clouds through wavelets
• Witnessing the fragmentation of a filament into prestellar cores in Orion B/NGC 2024
• Dissecting the super-critical filaments embedded in the 0.5 pc subsonic region of Barnard 5
• Statistical model for filamentary structures of molecular clouds -- The modified multiplicative random cascade model and its multifractal nature
• Modelling the chemistry of star-forming filaments - II. Testing filament characteristics with synthetic observations
• The straight and isolated G350.54+0.69 filament: density profile and star formation content
• How the power spectrum of dust continuum images may hide the presence of a characteristic filament width
• The Cygnus Allscale Survey of Chemistry and Dynamical Environments: CASCADE: Overview and first results toward DR20 from the Max Planck IRAM Observatory program (MIOP)
• Sheets, filaments and clumps - high resolution simulations of how the thermal instability can form molecular clouds
• The widths of magnetised filaments in molecular clouds
• Dust in the Wind with Resonant Drag Instabilities: I. The Dynamics of Dust-Driven Outflows in GMCs and HII Regions
• The origin of a universal filament width in molecular clouds
• Atacama Large Aperture Submillimeter Telescope (AtLAST) Science: Our Galaxy
• Synthetic line and continuum observations of simulated turbulent clouds: the apparent widths of filaments
• The discovery of the largest gas filament in our Galaxy, or a new spiral arm?
• Gravitational instability of filamentary molecular clouds, including ambipolar diffusion; Non-isothermal filament
• Formation of dust filaments in the diffuse envelopes of molecular clouds
• Velocity-Coherent Substructure in TMC-1: Inflow and Fragmentation
• Exposing the plural nature of molecular clouds : Extracting filaments and the CIB against the true scale-free interstellar medium
• Non-ideal magnetohydrodynamics of self-gravitating filaments
• A systematic bias in fitting the surface-density profiles of interstellar filaments
• Line emission from filaments in molecular clouds
• Symmetry properties and widths of the filamentary structures in the Orion A giant molecular cloud
• Emergence of high-mass stars in complex fiber networks (EMERGE) IV. Environmental dependence of the fiber widths
• Investigations of MWISP Filaments. I. Filament Identification and Analysis Algorithms, and Source Catalogue
• Comparison of Herschel and ArTéMiS observations of massive filaments
• Non-parametric Bayesian reconstruction of Galactic magnetic fields using Information Field Theory: The inclusion of line-of-sight information in ultra-high energy cosmic ray backtracking
• Scale-dependent surface and volume density properties of filaments in molecular clouds
• The influence of magnetic fields in Cloud-Cloud Collisions
• Interstellar filament detection and characterization: methods and implications for studies of magnetized interstellar medium
• Direct power spectral density estimation from structure functions without Fourier transforms
• A complete survey of filaments in Cygnus X
• Sutra : An integrated framework for identification and characterization of filaments in the interstellar medium