Covariance and objectivity in mechanics and turbulence
arXiv:1611.07002
Abstract
Form-invariance (covariance) and frame-indifference (objectivity) are two notions in classical continuum mechanics which have attracted much attention and controversy over the past decades. Particularly in turbulence modelling it seems that there still is a need for clarification. The aim and purpose of this study is fourfold: (i) To achieve consensus in general on definitions and principles when trying to establish an invariant theory for modelling constitutive structures and dynamic processes in mechanics, where special focus is put on the principle of Material Frame-Indifference (MFI). (ii) To show that in constitutive modelling MFI can only be regarded as an approximation that needs to be reduced to a weaker statement when trying to advance it to an axiom of nature. (iii) To convince that in dynamical modelling, as in turbulence, MFI may not be utilized as a modelling guideline, not even in an approximative sense. Instead, its reduced form has to be supplemented by a second, independent axiom that includes the microscopic (fluctuating) description of the dynamical processes. Concerning Navier-Stokes turbulence, the axiom of Turbulent Frame-Indifference (TFI) is stated in which turbulence has to be modelled consistently with the invariant properties of the deterministic Navier-Stokes equations, and finally (iv) to propose a novel invariant modelling ansatz both for constitutive and dynamical modelling that allows to include the (mean) velocity field as an own independent modelling variable, however, not in an absolute but only in the relative sense as a velocity difference; a result that would systematically improve current modelling procedures in extended thermodynamics and turbulence theory to be more consistent with physical observations.
arXiv comment43 pages
References in corpus (10)
- Can material time derivative be objective?
- A critical examination of the statistical symmetries admitted by the Lundgren-Monin-Novikov hierarchy of unconfined turbulence
- On the physical inconsistency of a new statistical scaling symmetry in incompressible Navier-Stokes turbulence
- A note on the notion "statistical symmetry"
- Two-dimensionalization of the flow driven by a slowly rotating impeller in a rapidly rotating fluid
- Application of Lie-group symmetry analysis to an infinite hierarchy of differential equations at the example of first order ODEs
- An example elucidating the mathematical situation in the statistical non-uniqueness problem of turbulence
- Revisiting the Lie-group symmetry method for turbulent channel flow with wall transpiration
- Comment on: I-Shih Liu: Constitutive theory of anisotropic rigid heat conductors
- On the use of applying Lie-group symmetry analysis to turbulent channel flow with streamwise rotation