Revisiting Evidence of Chaos in X-ray Light Curves: The Case of GRS 1915+105

Abstract

Nonlinear time series analysis has been widely used to search for signatures of low-dimensional chaos in light curves emanating from astrophysical bodies. A particularly popular example is the microquasar GRS 1915+105, whose irregular but systematic X-ray variability has been well studied using data acquired by the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer. With a view to building simpler models of X-ray variability, attempts have been made to classify the light curves of GRS 1915+105 as chaotic or stochastic. Contrary to some of the earlier suggestions, after careful analysis, we find no evidence for chaos or determinism in any of the GRS 1915+105 classes. The dearth of long and stationary data sets representing all the different variability classes of GRS 1915+105 makes it a poor candidate for analysis using nonlinear time series techniques. We conclude that either very exhaustive data analysis with sufficiently long and stationary light curves should be performed, keeping all the pitfalls of nonlinear time series analysis in mind, or alternative schemes of classifying the light curves should be adopted. The generic limitations of the techniques that we point out in the context of GRS 1915+105 affect all similar investigations of light curves from other astrophysical sources.

arXiv comment14 pages, 6 figures; minor corrections; slightly shorter version published in ApJ

References in corpus (26)

• Improved surrogate data for nonlinearity tests
• Surrogate time series
• GRS 1915+105 and the Disc-Jet Coupling in Accreting Black Hole Systems
• Nonlinear time-series analysis revisited
• Interdisciplinary application of nonlinear time series methods
• The Physics of the 'Heartbeat' State of GRS 1915+105
• Rapid Bursts From GRS 1915+105 with RXTE
• Strange nonchaotic stars
• Characterizing a new class of variability in GRS 1915+105 with simultaneous INTEGRAL/RXTE observations
• The prediction of future from the past: an old problem from a modern perspective
• Nonlinear Analysis of the Lightcurve of the Variable Star R Scuti
• The Harmonic and Sideband Structure of the Kilohertz Quasi-Periodic Oscillations in Sco X-1
• Uniform framework for the recurrence-network analysis of chaotic time series
• Chaos in Turbulence Driven by the Magnetorotational Instability
• Evidence for Low-Dimensional Chaos in Semiregular Variable Stars
• The chaotic behavior of the black hole system GRS 1915+105
• Linear and nonlinear time series analysis of the black hole candidate Cygnus X-1
• Chaotic and stochastic processes in the accretion flows of the black hole X-ray binaries revealed by recurrence analysis
• On the Nature of X-ray Variability in Ark 564
• Testing the X-ray variability of active galactic nuclei with the nonlinear prediction method
• Nonlinear time series anaysis of the light curves from the black hole system GRS1915+105
• Non-linear oscillator models for the X-ray bursting of the microquasar GRS 1915+105
• Search for chaos in neutron star systems: Is Cyg X-3 a black hole?
• Correlated spectral and temporal changes in 3C 390.3: a new link between AGN and Galactic Black Hole Binaries?
• Stochastic variability in X-ray emission from the black hole binary GRS 1915+105
• A search for chaos in the optical light curve of a blazar: W2R 1926+42

Cited by in corpus (10)

• Determination of chaotic behaviour in time series generated by charged particle motion around magnetized Schwarzschild black holes
• A comprehensive power spectral density analysis of astronomical time series I: the Fermi-LAT gamma-ray light curves of selected blazars
• Order out of Randomness : Self-Organization Processes in Astrophysics
• Copy the dynamics using a learning machine
• Inferring Global Dynamics Using a Learning Machine
• Inferring Global Dynamics of a Black-Box System Using Machine Learning
• On the Applicability of Low-Dimensional Models for Convective Flow Reversals at Extreme Prandtl Numbers
• Correlating nonlinear properties with spectral states of RXTE data: Possible observational evidences for four different accretion modes around compact objects
• Tracking hidden magnetospheric fluctuations in accretion-powered pulsars with a Kalman filter
• Searching for signatures of chaos in gamma-ray light curves of selected Fermi-LAT blazars