Voigt transformations in retrospect: missed opportunities?
arXiv:1609.08647
Abstract
The teaching of modern physics often uses the history of physics as a didactic tool. However, as in this process the history of physics is not something studied but used, there is a danger that the history itself will be distorted in, as Butterfield calls it, a "Whiggish" way, when the present becomes the measure of the past. It is not surprising that reading today a paper written more than a hundred years ago, we can extract much more of it than was actually thought or dreamed by the author himself. We demonstrate this Whiggish approach on the example of Woldemar Voigt's 1887 paper. From the modern perspective, it may appear that this paper opens a way to both the special relativity and to its anisotropic Finslerian generalization which came into the focus only recently, in relation with the Cohen and Glashow's very special relativity proposal. With a little imagination, one can connect Voigt's paper to the notorious Einstein-Poincare priority dispute, which we believe is a Whiggish late time artifact. We use the related historical circumstances to give a broader view on special relativity, than it is usually anticipated.
arXiv comment36 pages, no figures, revtex4, version to appear in Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie
References in corpus (14)
- Superfluid analogies of cosmological phenomena
- General Very Special Relativity is Finsler Geometry
- On the Advancements of Conformal Transformations and their Associated Symmetries in Geometry and Theoretical Physics
- Lifting General Relativity to Observer Space
- Conformal Invariance and Electrodynamics: Applications and General Formalism
- Relativistic Kinematics and Stationary Motions
- Breaking the light speed barrier
- On the Origin of the Lorentz Transformation
- Holographic Special Relativity
- On the relativistic unification of electricity and magnetism
- Spatial Directions, Anisotropy and Special Relativity
- Poincaré's Dynamics of the Electron - A Theory of Relativity?
- Max Born, Albert Einstein and Hermann Minkowski's Space-Time Formalism of Special Relativity
- Poincare and Special Relativity