Momentum of superconducting electrons and the explanation of the Meissner effect

Abstract

Momentum and energy conservation are fundamental tenets of physics, that valid physical theories have to satisfy. In the reversible transformation between superconducting and normal phases in the presence of a magnetic field, the mechanical momentum of the supercurrent has to be transferred to the body as a whole and vice versa, the kinetic energy of the supercurrent stays in the electronic degrees of freedom, and no energy is dissipated nor entropy is generated in the process. We argue on general grounds that to explain these processes it is necessary that the electromagnetic field mediates the transfer of momentum between electrons and the body as a whole, and this requires that when the phase boundary between normal and superconducting phases is displaced, a flow and counterflow of charge occurs in direction perpendicular to the phase boundary. This flow and counterflow does not occur according to the conventional BCS-London theory of superconductivity, therefore we argue that within BCS-London theory the Meissner transition is a `forbidden transition'. Furthermore, to explain the phase transformation in a way that is consistent with the experimental observations requires that (i) the wavefunction $and$ charge distribution of superconducting electrons near the phase boundary extend into the normal phase, and (ii) that the charge carriers in the normal state have hole-like character. The conventional theory of superconductivity does not have these physical elements, the theory of hole superconductivity does.

Appendix B added in response to reviewer's comments

References in corpus (3)

• Spin Meissner Effect in Superconductors and the Origin of the Meissner Effect
• Kinetic energy driven superconductivity, the origin of the Meissner effect, and the reductionist frontier
• Charge expulsion, Spin Meissner effect, and charge inhomogeneity in superconductors

Cited by in corpus (18)

• The law of entropy increase and the Meissner effect
• Flux trapping in superconducting hydrides under high pressure
• Joule heating in the normal-superconductor phase transition in a magnetic field
• Does the Meissner effect violate the second law of thermodynamics? Comment on "The Law of Entropy Increase and the Meissner Effect" by A. Nikulov
• Theory of Supercurrent in Superconductors
• London moment, London's superpotential, Nambu-Goldstone mode, and Berry connection from many-body wave functions
• Magnetic flux expulsion in a superconducting wire
• Method to extracting the penetration field in superconductors from DC magnetization data
• Alfven-like waves along normal-superconductor phase boundaries
• Belief in thermodynamics has provoked false thermodynamics of superconductors
• A problem with the conservation law observed in macroscopic quantum phenomena is a consequence of violation of the correspondence principle
• The Meissner effect in superconductors: emergence versus reductionism
• Berry connection from many-body wave functions and superconductivity: Calculations by the particle number conserving Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations
• Toward the detection of spin-vortex-induced loop currents in a single bilayer Bi${}_2$Sr${}_2$CaCu${}_2$O${}_{8+\delta }$ thin film and their possible use as qubits: Model calculations for three nano-island architecture
• What holes in superconductors reveal about superconductivity
• Berry connection from many-body wave functions and superconductivity: Circuit quantization for superconducting qubits and absence of a dissipative quantum phase transition in Josephson junctions
• The Meissner effect does not require radial charge flow
• Cooper pair ring model