Geometrically Exact Finite Element Formulations for Curved Slender Beams: Kirchhoff-Love Theory vs. Simo-Reissner Theory

Abstract

The present work focuses on geometrically exact finite elements for highly slender beams. It aims at the proposal of novel formulations of Kirchhoff-Love type, a detailed review of existing formulations of Kirchhoff-Love and Simo-Reissner type as well as a careful evaluation and comparison of the proposed and existing formulations. Two different rotation interpolation schemes with strong or weak Kirchhoff constraint enforcement, respectively, as well as two different choices of nodal triad parametrizations in terms of rotation or tangent vectors are proposed. The combination of these schemes leads to four novel finite element variants, all of them based on a C1-continuous Hermite interpolation of the beam centerline. Essential requirements such as representability of general 3D, large-deformation, dynamic problems involving slender beams with arbitrary initial curvatures and anisotropic cross-section shapes or preservation of objectivity and path-independence will be investigated analytically and verified numerically for the different formulations. It will be shown that the geometrically exact Kirchhoff-Love beam elements proposed in this work are the first ones of this type that fulfill all the considered requirements. On the contrary, Simo-Reissner type formulations fulfilling these requirements can be found in the literature very well. However, it will be argued that the shear-free Kirchhoff-Love formulations can provide considerable numerical advantages when applied to highly slender beams. Concretely, several representative numerical test cases confirm that the proposed Kirchhoff-Love formulations exhibit a lower discretization error level as well as a considerably improved nonlinear solver performance in the range of high beam slenderness ratios as compared to two representative Simo-Reissner element formulations from the literature.

References in corpus (2)

• A Unified Approach for Beam-to-Beam Contact
• A Finite Element Approach for the Line-to-Line Contact Interaction of Thin Beams with Arbitrary Orientation

Cited by in corpus (23)

• Geometrically exact beam elements and smooth contact schemes for the modeling of fiber-based materials and structures
• Finite Element Formulations for Beam-to-Solid Interaction -- From Embedded Fibers Towards Contact
• A mortar-type finite element approach for embedding 1D beams into 3D solid volumes
• An isogeometric finite element formulation for geometrically exact Timoshenko beams with extensible directors
• Consistent coupling of positions and rotations for embedding 1D Cosserat beams into 3D solid volumes
• A total Lagrangian, objective and intrinsically locking-free Petrov-Galerkin SE(3) Cosserat rod finite element formulation
• Geometrically exact static isogeometric analysis of an arbitrarily curved spatial Bernoulli-Euler beam
• Geometrically exact static isogeometric analysis of arbitrarily curved plane Bernoulli-Euler beam
• Geometrically exact isogeometric Bernoulli-Euler beam based on the Frenet-Serret frame
• Multidimensional coupling: A variationally consistent approach to fiber-reinforced materials
• An SPH framework for fluid-solid and contact interaction problems including thermo-mechanical coupling and reversible phase transitions
• Physics-augmented neural networks for constitutive modeling of hyperelastic geometrically exact beams
• A family of total Lagrangian Petrov-Galerkin Cosserat rod finite element formulations
• Variational principles for nonlinear Kirchhoff rods
• A Novel Modeling and Simulation Approach for the Hindered Mobility of Charged Particles in Biological Hydrogels
• An approximate block factorization preconditioner for mixed-dimensional beam-solid interaction
• Towards understanding structure-function relationships in random fiber networks
• A consistent mixed-dimensional coupling approach for 1D Cosserat beams and 2D surfaces in 3D space
• An objective isogeometric mixed finite element formulation for nonlinear elastodynamic beams with incompatible warping strains
• A discontinuous Galerkin / cohesive zone model approach for the computational modeling of fracture in geometrically exact slender beams
• A variationally consistent beam-to-beam point coupling formulation for geometrically exact beam theories
• A study on nodal and isogeometric formulations for nonlinear dynamics of shear- and torsion-free rods
• Mixed Finite Elements for Geometrically Exact Beams using Discontinuous Rotations and Discrete Curvature