On Kottler's path: origin and evolution of the premetric program in gravity and in electrodynamics

Abstract

In 1922, Kottler put forward the program to remove the gravitational potential, the metric of spacetime, from the fundamental equations in physics as far as possible. He successfully applied this idea to Newton's gravitostatics and to Maxwell's electrodynamics, where Kottler recast the field equations in premetric form and specified a metric-dependent constitutive law. We will discuss the basics of the premetric approach and some of its beautiful consequences, like the division of universal constants into two classes. We show that classical electrodynamics can be developed without a metric quite straightforwardly: the Maxwell equations, together with a local and linear response law for electromagnetic media, admit a consistent premetric formulation. Kottler's program succeeds here without provisos. In Kottler's approach to gravity, making the theory relativistic, two premetric quasi-Maxwellian field equations arise, but their field variables, if interpreted in terms of general relativity, do depend on the metric. However, one can hope to bring the Kottler idea to work by using the teleparallelism equivalent of general relativity, where the gravitational potential, the coframe, can be chosen in a premetric way.

72 pages latex with 6 figures; based on an invited talk given at the Annual Meeting of the German Physical Society (DPG) in Berlin on 20 March 2015, Working Group on Philosophy of Physics (AGPhil); a short version will be submitted to IJMPD

References in corpus (66)

• CODATA Recommended Values of the Fundamental Physical Constants: 2010
• Magnetoelectric polarizability and axion electrodynamics in crystalline insulators
• The teleparallel equivalent of general relativity
• Thermal generation of spin current in an antiferromagnet
• Gravito-electromagnetism
• The Many Faces of Gravitoelectromagnetism
• Metric-affine approach to teleparallel gravity
• Gravitoelectromagnetism: A Brief Review
• Fresnel analysis of the wave propagation in nonlinear electrodynamics
• POLARBEAR Constraints on Cosmic Birefringence and Primordial Magnetic Fields
• Riemannian light cone from vanishing birefringence in premetric vacuum electrodynamics
• Gauge Symmetry and Gravito-Electromagnetism
• Measuring a piecewise constant axion field in classical electrodynamics
• Relativistic nature of a magnetoelectric modulus of Cr_2O_3-crystals: a new 4-dimensional pseudoscalar and its measurement
• Linear media in classical electrodynamics and the Post constraint
• Gravitomagnetic effects
• Linear pre-metric electrodynamics and deduction of the light cone
• Is the Lorentz signature of the metric of spacetime electromagnetic in origin?
• Relativistic analysis of magnetoelectric crystals: extracting a new 4-dimensional P odd and T odd pseudoscalar from Cr_2 O_3 data
• Wave propagation in linear electrodynamics
• Finslerian spaces possessing local relativistic symmetry
• Magnetoelectric Cr_2 O_3 and relativity theory
• Energy-momentum current for coframe gravity
• On light propagation in premetric electrodynamics. Covariant dispersion relation
• Causal structure and algebraic classification of area metric spacetimes in four dimensions
• On possible skewon effects on light propagation
• Is the Quantum Hall Effect influenced by the gravitational field?
• The non-birefringent limit of all linear, skewonless media and its unique light-cone structure
• To consider the electromagnetic field as fundamental, and the metric only as a subsidiary field
• Dimensions and Units in Electrodynamics
• Physical principles underlying the quantum Hall effect
• On the theory of the skewon field: From electrodynamics to gravity
• No-birefringence conditions for spacetime
• Spacetime structure and asymmetric metric from the premetric formulation of electromagnetism
• Light propagation in local and linear media: Fresnel-Kummer wave surfaces with 16 singular points
• Spacetime metric from local and linear electrodynamics: a new axiomatic scheme
• Spin-axion coupling
• Stress and Hyperstress as Fundamental Concepts in Continuum Mechanics and in Relativistic Field Theory
• On the measure of spacetime and gravity
• Skewon field and cosmic wave propagation
• Searches for the role of spin and polarization in gravity: a five-year update
• The Kummer tensor density in electrodynamics and in gravity
• Light propagation in generally covariant electrodynamics and the Fresnel equation
• New constraints on cosmic polarization rotation from the ACTPol cosmic microwave background B-Mode polarization observation and the BICEP2 constraint update
• Dilaton field and cosmic wave propagation
• Gravitational waves and electrodynamics: New perspectives
• Boundary value problems and the validity of the Post constraint in modern electromagnetism
• Axionic extension of the Einstein-aether theory
• Electromagnetic Potential in Pre-Metric Electrodynamics: Causal Structure, Propagators and Quantization
• The relativistic electron gas: a candidate for nature's left-handed material
• Electrodynamics of a Cosmic Dark Fluid
• Determination of electromagnetic medium from the Fresnel surface
• Plebański-Demiański solution of general relativity and its expressions quadratic and cubic in curvature: analogies to electromagnetism
• Backwards on Minkowski's road. From 4D to 3D Maxwellian electromagnetism
• Equivalence Principles, Spacetime Structure and the Cosmic Connection
• How Special Relativity Determines the Signs of the Nonrelativistic, Coulomb and Newtonian, Forces
• On linear electromagnetic constitutive laws that define almost-complex structures
• Geometry of Area Without Length
• Electrodynamics and spacetime geometry: Astrophysical applications
• A restatement of the normal form theorem for area metrics
• Covariant jump conditions in electromagnetism
• Axiomatics of classical electrodynamics and its relation to gauge field theory
• On Onsager Relations and Linear Electromagnetic Materials
• Plane-Wave Propagation in Extreme Magnetoelectric (EME) Media
• Babel of Units. The Evolution of Units Systems in Classical Electromagnetism
• Axion and dilaton + metric emerge from local and linear electrodynamics

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Teleparallel Palatini theories
• Teleparallel theories of gravity as analogue of non-linear electrodynamics
• On the matter of topological insulators as magnetoelectrics
• General treatment of quantum and classical spinning particles in external fields
• Variational Principles in Teleparallel Gravity Theories
• Premetric equivalent of general relativity: Teleparallelism
• Premetric teleparallel theory of gravity and its local and linear constitutive law
• An axiomatic purification of gravity
• General relativity as a special case of Poincaré gauge gravity
• Pregeometric First Order Yang-Mills Theory
• Classification of primary constraints for new general relativity in the premetric approach
• Conservation of energy-momentum of matter as the basis for the gauge theory of gravitation
• Flux Quantization
• Flux Quantization on Phase Space
• The Distributional Stress-Energy Quadrupole
• Light propagation in (2+1)-dimensional electrodynamics: the case of linear constitutive laws
• Physical dimensions/units and universal constants: their invariance in special and general relativity
• Quantum Observables of Quantized Fluxes
• On spacetime structure and electrodynamics
• Remarks on the algebraic structure of (2, 2) double forms
• Self-Excited Gravitational Instantons
• The explicit form of the unitary representation of the Poincaré group for vector-valued wave functions (massive and massless), with applications to photon's localization and position operators