Testing Hydrodynamics Schemes in Galaxy Disc Simulations
arXiv:1605.09792 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stw1226
Abstract
We examine how three fundamentally different numerical hydrodynamics codes follow the evolution of an isothermal galactic disc with an external spiral potential. We compare an adaptive mesh refinement code (RAMSES), a smoothed particle hydrodynamics code (sphNG), and a volume-discretised meshless code (GIZMO). Using standard refinement criteria, we find that RAMSES produces a disc that is less vertically concentrated and does not reach such high densities as the sphNG or GIZMO runs. The gas surface density in the spiral arms increases at a lower rate for the RAMSES simulations compared to the other codes. There is also a greater degree of substructure in the sphNG and GIZMO runs and secondary spiral arms are more pronounced. By resolving the Jeans' length with a greater number of grid cells we achieve more similar results to the Lagrangian codes used in this study. Other alterations to the refinement scheme (adding extra levels of refinement and refining based on local density gradients) are less successful in reducing the disparity between RAMSES and sphNG/GIZMO. Although more similar, sphNG displays different density distributions and vertical mass profiles to all modes of GIZMO (including the smoothed particle hydrodynamics version). This suggests differences also arise which are not intrinsic to the particular method but rather due to its implementation. The discrepancies between codes (in particular, the densities reached in the spiral arms) could potentially result in differences in the locations and timescales for gravitational collapse, and therefore impact star formation activity in more complex galaxy disc simulations.
arXiv commentPublished in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: http://mnras.oxfordjournals.org/content/460/4/4382
References in corpus (60)
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Cosmological Hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: a new high resolution code called RAMSES
- Galaxies on FIRE (Feedback In Realistic Environments): Stellar Feedback Explains Cosmologically Inefficient Star Formation
- GIZMO: A New Class of Accurate, Mesh-Free Hydrodynamic Simulation Methods
- The Inner Structure of LambdaCDM Halos I: A Numerical Convergence Study
- Modelling Accretion in Protobinary Systems
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
- The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- A General Class of Lagrangian Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Methods and Implications for Fluid Mixing Problems
- Gravitational Collapse in Turbulent Molecular Clouds. I. Gasdynamical Turbulence
- Modelling discontinuities and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in SPH
- Simulations of magnetic fields in isolated disk galaxies
- Inviscid SPH
- Fully Threaded Tree for Adaptive Refinement Fluid Dynamics Simulations
- Molecular Hydrogen and Global Star Formation Relations in Galaxies
- Star Formation in Disk Galaxies. I. Formation and Evolution of Giant Molecular Clouds via Gravitational Instability and Cloud Collisions
- The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project
- Reformulation of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with Riemann Solver
- ISM properties in hydrodynamic galaxy simulations: Turbulence cascades, cloud formation, role of gravity and feedback
- CO-dark gas and molecular filaments in Milky Way type galaxies
- A sub-parsec resolution simulation of the Milky Way: Global structure of the ISM and properties of molecular clouds
- A Necessary Condition for Individual Time-Steps in SPH Simulations
- Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
- Implementation of feedback in SPH: towards concordance of methods
- The Exciting Lives of Giant Molecular Clouds
- A Density Independent Formulation of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- The dynamics of stars around spiral arms
- Formation and Fragmentation of Gaseous Spurs in Spiral Galaxies
- Multiphase Smoothed-Particle Hydrodynamics
- Smoothed Particle Magnetohydrodynamics II. Variational principles and variable smoothing length terms
- Toward first-principle simulations of galaxy formation: I. How should we choose star formation criteria in high-resolution simulations of disk galaxies?
- A test suite for quantitative comparison of hydrodynamics codes in astrophysics
- Stellar Feedback & Bulge Formation in Clumpy Disks
- Formation of Spiral-Arm Spurs and Bound Clouds in Vertically Stratified Galactic Gas Disks
- Density structure of the interstellar medium and the star formation rate in galactic disks
- A simulation of galaxy formation and clustering
- Moving mesh cosmology: characteristics of galaxies and haloes
- Comparing Numerical Methods for Isothermal Magnetized Supersonic Turbulence
- Instabilities of Spiral Shocks I: Onset of Wiggle Instability and its Mechanism
- Global Modeling of Spur Formation in Spiral Galaxies
- The formation of molecular clouds in spiral galaxies
- Moving Mesh Cosmology: Properties of Gas Disks
- A comparison between grid and particle methods on the statistics of driven, supersonic, isothermal turbulence
- Analytical Expressions for Spiral Arm Gravitational Potential and Density
- The ISM in spiral galaxies: can cooling in spiral shocks produce molecular clouds?
- Astrophysical Weighted Particle Magnetohydrodynamics
- Algorithmic comparisons of decaying, isothermal, supersonic turbulence
- Do Giant Molecular Clouds Care About the Galactic Structure?
- Branch, Spur, and Feather Formation in Spiral Galaxies
- Instabilities of Spiral Shocks -- II. A quasi-steady State in the multi-phase inhomogeneous ISM
- Mixing and transport of metals by gravitational instability-driven turbulence in galactic discs
- Characterizing gravitational instability in turbulent multi-component galactic discs
- The simulation of molecular clouds formation in the Milky Way
- Star Formation in Disk Galaxies. III. Does stellar feedback result in cloud death?
- Feathering Instability of Spiral Arms. II. Parameter Study
- Analysis of the spiral structure in a simulated galaxy
- Effective viscosity from cloud-cloud collisions in three-dimensional global SPH simulations
- Cloud angular momentum and effective viscosity in global SPH simulations with feedback
Cited by in corpus (17)
- FIRE-2 Simulations: Physics versus Numerics in Galaxy Formation
- The Auriga Project: the properties and formation mechanisms of disc galaxies across cosmic time
- Gas kinematics, morphology, and angular momentum in the FIRE simulations
- STARFORGE: Toward a comprehensive numerical model of star cluster formation and feedback
- The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. II: Isolated Disk Test
- GMC Collisions as Triggers of Star Formation. III. Density and Magnetically Regulated Star Formation
- Gas Dynamics in the Galaxy: Total Mass Distribution and the Bar Pattern Speed
- Star formation and ISM morphology in tidally induced spiral structures
- Tidal origin of spiral arms in galaxies orbiting a cluster
- Testing the Prediction of Fuzzy Dark Matter Theory in the Milky Way Center
- Magnetic field evolution and reversals in spiral galaxies
- The properties, origin and evolution of stellar clusters in galaxy simulations and observations
- EDGE: A new approach to suppressing numerical diffusion in adaptive mesh simulations of galaxy formation
- Rapid formation of black holes in galaxies: a self-limiting growth mechanism
- The Gaia-ESO Survey: Matching Chemo-Dynamical Simulations to Observations of the Milky Way
- Resolution Convergence in Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations Using Adaptive Mesh Refinement
- Gasflows in Barred Galaxies with Big Orbital Loops-A Comparative Study of Two Hydrocodes