The Ambiguity of Simplicity

Abstract

A system's apparent simplicity depends on whether it is represented classically or quantally. This is not so surprising, as classical and quantum physics are descriptive frameworks built on different assumptions that capture, emphasize, and express different properties and mechanisms. What is surprising is that, as we demonstrate, simplicity is ambiguous: the relative simplicity between two systems can change sign when moving between classical and quantum descriptions. Thus, notions of absolute physical simplicity---minimal structure or memory---at best form a partial, not a total, order. This suggests that appeals to principles of physical simplicity, via Ockham's Razor or to the "elegance" of competing theories, may be fundamentally subjective, perhaps even beyond the purview of physics itself. It also raises challenging questions in model selection between classical and quantum descriptions. Fortunately, experiments are now beginning to probe measures of simplicity, creating the potential to directly test for ambiguity.

arXiv comment7 pages, 6 figures, http://csc.ucdavis.edu/~cmg/compmech/pubs/aos.htm

References in corpus (11)

• Weak pairwise correlations imply strongly correlated network states in a neural population
• Occam's Quantum Razor: How Quantum Mechanics can reduce the complexity of classical models
• Equation of State of Ultracold Fermions in the 2D BEC-BCS Crossover Region
• Structural Information in Two-Dimensional Patterns: Entropy Convergence and Excess Entropy
• Thermodynamics of an attractive 2D Fermi gas
• Bayesian Structural Inference for Hidden Processes
• Experimental quantum processing enhancement in modelling stochastic processes
• A Closed-Form Shave from Occam's Quantum Razor: Exact Results for Quantum Compression
• Many Roads to Synchrony: Natural Time Scales and Their Algorithms
• The classical-quantum divergence of complexity in modelling spin chains
• Demonstration of Turnstiles as a Chaotic Ionization Mechanism in Rydberg Atoms

Cited by in corpus (3)

• The Markov Memory for Generating Rare Events
• Extreme Quantum Advantage when Simulating Strongly Coupled Classical Systems
• The Origins of Computational Mechanics: A Brief Intellectual History and Several Clarifications