Accuracy requirements to test the applicability of the random cascade model to supersonic turbulence
arXiv:1602.02121 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201527148
Abstract
A model, which is widely used for inertial rang statistics of supersonic turbulence in the context of molecular clouds and star formation, expresses (measurable) relative scaling exponents Z_p of two-point velocity statistics as a function of two parameters, beta and Delta. The model relates them to the dimension D of the most dissipative structures, D=3-Delta/(1-beta). While this description has proved most successful for incompressible turbulence (beta=Delta=2/3, and D=1), its applicability in the highly compressible regime remains debated. For this regime, theoretical arguments suggest D=2 and Delta=2/3, or Delta=1. Best estimates based on 3D periodic box simulations of supersonic isothermal turbulence yield Delta=0.71 and D=1.9, with uncertainty ranges of Delta in [0.67, 0.78] and D in [2.04,1.60]. With these 5-10\% uncertainty ranges just marginally including the theoretical values of Delta=2/3 and D=2, doubts remain whether the model indeed applies and, if it applies, for what values of beta and Delta. We use a Monte Carlo approach to mimic actual simulation data and examine what factors are most relevant for the fit quality. We estimate that 0.1% (0.05%) accurate Z_p, with p=1...5, should allow for 2% (1%) accurate estimates of beta and Delta in the highly compressible regime, but not in the mildly compressible regime. We argue that simulation-based Z_p with such accuracy are within reach of today's computer resources. If this kind of data does not allow for the expected high quality fit of beta and Delta, then this may indicate the inapplicability of the model for the simulation data. In fact, other models than the one we examine here have been suggested.
arXiv comment8 pages, 8 figures, accepted by Astronomy and Astrophysics
References in corpus (24)
- The Star Formation Rate of Turbulent Magnetized Clouds: Comparing Theory, Simulations, and Observations
- The Statistics of Supersonic Isothermal Turbulence
- Analytical theory for the initial mass function: CO clumps and prestellar cores
- On the universality of supersonic turbulence
- Numerical simulations of compressively driven interstellar turbulence: I. Isothermal gas
- A Simple Law of Star Formation
- Kolmogorov-Burgers Model for Star Forming Turbulence
- Bottleneck effect in three-dimensional turbulence simulations
- A Model for (Non-Lognormal) Density Distributions in Isothermal Turbulence
- Is the Scaling of Supersonic Turbulence Universal?
- 3D simulations of RS Oph: from accretion to nova blast
- Feeding SMBHs through supersonic turbulence and ballistic accretion
- Supersonic turbulence and structure of interstellar molecular clouds
- A supersonic turbulence origin of Larson's laws
- Structure Function Scaling in Compressible Super-Alfvenic MHD Turbulence
- A Turbulent Model of Gamma-Ray Burst Variability
- Spectra of strong MHD Turbulence from high-resolution simulations
- GRB Light Curves in the Relativistic Turbulence Model
- Dissipative Structures in Supersonic Turbulence
- Dimensional argument for the impact of turbulent support on the stellar initial mass function
- Scaling Laws and Intermittency in Highly Compressible Turbulence
- On the multifractal structure of fully developed turbulence
- Supersonic turbulence in 3D isothermal flow collision
- The nature of turbulence in OMC1 at the star forming scale: observations and simulations