On the relevance of bubbles and potential flows for stellar convection

Abstract

Recently Pasetto et al. have proposed a new method to derive a convection theory appropriate for the implementation in stellar evolution codes. Their approach is based on the simple physical picture of spherical bubbles moving within a potential flow in dynamically unstable regions, and a detailed computation of the bubble dynamics. Based on this approach the authors derive a new theory of convection which is claimed to be parameter free, non-local and time-dependent. This is a very strong claim, as such a theory is the holy grail of stellar physics. Unfortunately we have identified several distinct problems in the derivation which ultimately render their theory inapplicable to any physical regime. In addition we show that the framework of spherical bubbles in potential flows is unable to capture the essence of stellar convection, even when equations are derived correctly.

14 pages, 3 figures. Accepted for publication in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. (Comments and criticism are welcomed)

References in corpus (7)

• Improvements to stellar structure models, based on a grid of 3D convection simulations. II. Calibrating the mixing-length formulation
• The Stagger-grid: A grid of 3D stellar atmosphere models - III. The relation to mixing-length convection theory
• Beyond Mixing-length Theory: a step toward 321D
• Toward a consistent use of overshooting parametrizations in 1D stellar evolution codes
• Calibration of the Mixing-Length Theory for Convective White Dwarf Envelopes
• A closure model with plumes I. The solar convection
• Theory of stellar convection: Removing the Mixing-Length Parameter

Cited by in corpus (3)

• Radiative heating achieves the ultimate regime of thermal convection
• Problems for the WELS classification of planetary nebulae central stars: Self-consistent nebular modelling of four candidates
• Slow convection and fast rotation in crystallization-driven white dwarf dynamos