On spurious detection of linear response and misuse of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem in finite time series

Abstract

Using a sensitive statistical test we determine whether or not one can detect the breakdown of linear response given observations of deterministic dynamical systems. A goodness-of-fit statistics is developed for a linear statistical model of the observations, based on results on central limit theorems for deterministic dynamical systems, and used to detect linear response breakdown. We apply the method to discrete maps which do not obey linear response and show that the successful detection of breakdown depends on the length of the time series, the magnitude of the perturbation and on the choice of the observable. We find that in order to reliably reject the assumption of linear response for typical observables sufficiently large data sets are needed. Even for simple systems such as the logistic map, one needs of the order of $10^6$ observations to reliably detect the breakdown, if less observations are available one may be falsely led to conclude that linear response theory is valid. The amount of data required is larger the smaller the applied perturbation. For judiciously chosen observables the necessary amount of data can be drastically reduced, but requires detailed {\em{a priori}} knowledge about the invariant measure which is typically not available for complex dynamical systems. Furthermore we explore the use of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) in cases with limited data length or coarse-graining of observations. The FDT, if applied naively to a system without linear response, is shown to be very sensitive to the details of the sampling method, resulting in erroneous predictions of the response.

Published in Physica D (2016)

References in corpus (7)

• Fluctuation-Dissipation: Response Theory in Statistical Physics
• A review of linear response theory for general differentiable dynamical systems
• A new framework for climate sensitivity and prediction: a modelling perspective
• Linear response for intermittent maps
• Linear response, susceptibility and resonances in chaotic toy models
• Linear response, or else
• Central limit theorem for the modulus of continuity of averages of observables on transversal families of piecewise expanding unimodal maps

Cited by in corpus (14)

• Quantification and interpretation of the climate variability record
• Can we use linear response theory to assess geoengineering strategies?
• Linear response for macroscopic observables in high-dimensional systems
• On the validity of linear response theory in high-dimensional deterministic dynamical systems
• Linear and fractional response for the SRB measure of smooth hyperbolic attractors and discontinuous observables
• Spectral Galerkin methods for transfer operators in uniformly expanding dynamics
• Response Formulae for $n$-point Correlations in Statistical Mechanical Systems and Application to a Problem of Coarse Graining
• Edgeworth expansions for slow-fast systems with finite time scale separation
• Conditional mixing in deterministic chaos
• A Parameter Estimation Method Using Linear Response Statistics: Numerical Scheme
• Correcting for Model Changes in Statistical Postprocessing -- An approach based on Response Theory
• A Parameter Estimation Method Using Linear Response Statistics
• Rigorous justification for the space-split sensitivity algorithm to compute linear response in Anosov systems
• On convergence of linear response formulae in some piecewise hyperbolic maps