Is flux rope a necessary condition for the progenitor of coronal mass ejections?

Abstract

A magnetic flux rope structure is believed to exist in most coronal mass ejections (CMEs). However, it has been long debated whether the flux rope exists before eruption or is formed during eruption via magnetic reconnection. The controversy has been continuing because of our lack of routine measurements of the magnetic field in the pre-eruption structure, such as solar filaments. However, recently an indirect method was proposed to infer the magnetic field configuration based on the sign of helicity and the bearing direction of the filament barbs. In this paper, we apply this method to two erupting filament events, one on 2014 September 2 and the other on 2011 March 7, and find that the first filament is supported by a magnetic flux rope and the second filament is supported by a sheared arcade, i.e., the first one is an inverse-polarity filament and the second one is a normal-polarity filament. With the identification of the magnetic configurations in these two filaments, we stress that a flux rope is not a necessary condition for the pre-CME structure.

26 pages, 11 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (8)

• Torus instability
• Formation of a Double-decker Magnetic Flux Rope in the Sigmoidal Solar Active Region 11520
• Structures of Interplanetary Magnetic Flux Ropes and Comparison with Their Solar Sources
• The magnetic field configuration of a solar prominence inferred from spectropolarimetric observations in the He I 10830 A triplet
• Direct observations of magnetic flux rope formation during a solar coronal mass ejection
• Unwinding motion of a twisted active-region filament
• Formation of a rotating jet during the filament eruption on 10-11 April 2013
• Multiwavelength observation of a large-scale flux rope eruption above kinked mini-filament

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Origin and Structures of Solar Eruptions I: Magnetic Flux Rope (Invited Review)
• Chirality and Magnetic Configurations of Solar Filaments
• Initiation and Early Kinematic Evolution of Solar Eruptions
• Some interesting topics provoked by the solar filament research in the past decade
• Witnessing tether-cutting reconnection at the onset of a partial eruption
• The formation of an inverse S-shaped active-region filament driven by sunspot motion and magnetic reconnection
• A Statistical Study of the Average Iron Charge Distributions inside Magnetic Clouds for Solar Cycle 23
• Thermodynamic and Magnetic Topology Evolution of the X1.0 Flare on 2021 October 28 Simulated by a Data-driven Radiative Magnetohydrodynamic Model
• Transition from circular-ribbon to parallel-ribbon flares associated with a bifurcated magnetic flux rope
• Material supply and magnetic configuration of an active region filament
• Toward a Unified Explanation for the Three-part Structure of Solar Coronal Mass Ejections
• Magnetic Twists of Solar Filaments
• The Structure of Coronal Mass Ejections Recorded by the K-Coronagraph at Mauna Loa Solar Observatory
• Dynamics evolution of a solar active-region filament from quasi-static state to eruption: rolling motion, untwisting motion, material transfer, and chirality
• Solar Cycle Dependence of ICME Composition
• Characteristics and applications of interplanetary coronal mass ejection composition
• A statistical study of the plasma and composition distribution inside magnetic clouds: 1998-2011
• A Prospective New Diagnostic Technique for Distinguishing Eruptive and Non-Eruptive Active Regions
• Composition Comparison between ICMEs from Active Regions and Quiet-Sun Regions
• The Inhomogeneity of Composition along the Magnetic Cloud Axis
• A new technique for observationally derived boundary conditions for space weather
• Extreme-ultraviolet Late Phase in Homologous Solar Flares from a Complex Active Region