Important issues facing model-based approaches to tunneling transport in molecular junctions

Abstract

Extensive studies on thin films indicated a generic cubic current-voltage $I-V$ dependence as a salient feature of charge transport by tunneling. A quick glance at $I-V$ data for molecular junctions suggests a qualitatively similar behavior. This would render model-based studies almost irrelevant, since, whatever the model, its parameters can always be adjusted to fit symmetric (asymmetric) $I-V$ curves characterized by two (three) expansion coefficients. Here, we systematically examine popular models based on tunneling barrier or tight-binding pictures and demonstrate that, for a quantitative description at biases of interest ($V$ slightly higher than the transition voltage $V_t$), cubic expansions do not suffice. A detailed collection of analytical formulae as well as their conditions of applicability are presented to facilitate experimentalists colleagues to process and interpret their experimental data by obtained by measuring currents in molecular junctions. We discuss in detail the limits of applicability of the various models and emphasize that uncritically adjusting model parameters to experiment may be unjustified because the values deduced in this way may fall in ranges rendering a specific model invalid or incompatible to ab initio estimates. We exemplify with the benchmark case of oligophenylene-based junctions, for which results of ab initio quantum chemical calculations are also reported. As a specific issue, we address the impact of the spatial potential profile and show that it is not notable up to biases V somewhat larger than V_t, unlike at higher biases, where it may be responsible for negative differential resistance effects.

A typo in eqn (23) of the printed article is corrected here

References in corpus (7)

• Molecule-Electrode Interface Energetics in Molecular Junction: a Transition Voltage Spectroscopy Study
• Conductance statistics from a large array of sub-10 nm molecular junctions
• On the Mechanical and Electronic Properties of Thiolated Gold Nanocrystals
• Sources of negative differential resistance in electric nanotransport
• Influence of Molecular Organization on the Electrical Characteristics of π-conjugated Self-assembled Monolayers
• Quantifying the relative molecular orbital alignment for molecular junctions with similar chemical linkage to electrodes
• Concurrent conductance and transition voltage spectroscopy study of scanning tunneling microscopy vacuum junctions. Does it unravel new physics?

Cited by in corpus (9)

• Large-area, ensemble molecular electronics: Motivation and challenges
• Redox-controlled conductance of polyoxometalate molecular junctions
• Why Asymmetric Molecular Coupling to Electrodes Cannot Be at Work in Real Molecular Rectifiers
• Counterintuitive issues in the charge transport through molecular junctions
• Can tunneling current in molecular junctions be so strongly temperature dependent to challenge a hopping mechanism? Analytical formulas answer this question and provide important insight into large area junctions
• Suppression of Groups Intermingling as Appealing Option For Flattening and Delaying the Epidemiological Curve While Allowing Economic and Social Life at Bearable Level During COVID-19 Pandemic
• First-principles molecular transport calculation for the benzenedithiolate molecule
• What Can We Learn from the Time Evolution of COVID-19 Epidemic in Slovenia?
• A Three-Tiered Hierarchical Computational Framework Bridging Molecular Systems and Junction-Level Charge Transport