Confounder Adjustment in Multiple Hypothesis Testing

Abstract

We consider large-scale studies in which thousands of significance tests are performed simultaneously. In some of these studies, the multiple testing procedure can be severely biased by latent confounding factors such as batch effects and unmeasured covariates that correlate with both primary variable(s) of interest (e.g. treatment variable, phenotype) and the outcome. Over the past decade, many statistical methods have been proposed to adjust for the confounders in hypothesis testing. We unify these methods in the same framework, generalize them to include multiple primary variables and multiple nuisance variables, and analyze their statistical properties. In particular, we provide theoretical guarantees for RUV-4 and LEAPP, which correspond to two different identification conditions in the framework: the first requires a set of "negative controls" that are known a priori to follow the null distribution; the second requires the true non-nulls to be sparse. Two different estimators which are based on RUV-4 and LEAPP are then applied to these two scenarios. We show that if the confounding factors are strong, the resulting estimators can be asymptotically as powerful as the oracle estimator which observes the latent confounding factors. For hypothesis testing, we show the asymptotic z-tests based on the estimators can control the type I error. Numerical experiments show that the false discovery rate is also controlled by the Benjamini-Hochberg procedure when the sample size is reasonably large.

arXiv commentThe first two authors contributed equally to this paper

References in corpus (11)

• In silico prediction of protein-protein interactions in human macrophages
• Latent variable graphical model selection via convex optimization
• Statistical analysis of factor models of high dimension
• Robustness of multiple testing procedures against dependence
• False discovery rate analysis of brain diffusion direction maps
• Theory and methods of panel data models with interactive effects
• Estimation of False Discovery Proportion with Unknown Dependence
• Degrees of freedom for combining regression with factor analysis
• A rate optimal procedure for sparse signal recovery under dependence
• A Factor-Adjusted Multiple Testing Procedure with Application to Mutual Fund Selection
• Bi-cross-validation for factor analysis