Are tornado-like magnetic structures able to support solar prominence plasma?

Abstract

Recent high-resolution and high-cadence observations have surprisingly suggested that prominence barbs exhibit apparent rotating motions suggestive of a tornado-like structure. Additional evidence has been provided by Doppler measurements. The observations reveal opposite velocities for both hot and cool plasma on the two sides of a prominence barb. This motion is persistent for several hours and has been interpreted in terms of rotational motion of prominence feet. Several authors suggest that such barb motions are rotating helical structures around a vertical axis similar to tornadoes on Earth. One of the difficulties of such a proposal is how to support cool prominence plasma in almost-vertical structures against gravity. In this work we model analytically a tornado-like structure and try to determine possible mechanisms to support the prominence plasma. We have found that the Lorentz force can indeed support the barb plasma provided the magnetic structure is sufficiently twisted and/or significant poloidal flows are present.

Accepted for publication in ApJL

References in corpus (5)

• Convectively driven vortex flows in the Sun
• Are giant tornadoes the legs of solar prominences?
• Apparent Solar Tornado - Like Prominences
• Solar Magnetized Tornadoes: Rotational Motion in a Tornado-like Prominence
• Spectro-polarimetric Imaging Reveals Helical Magnetic Fields in Solar Prominence Feet

Cited by in corpus (18)

• Magnetic field in atypical prominence structures: Bubble, tornado and eruption
• Structure of prominence legs: Plasma and magnetic field
• Reconstruction of a helical prominence in 3D from IRIS spectra and images
• Material supply and magnetic configuration of an active region filament
• Halpha Doppler shifts in a tornado in the solar corona
• Diagnostic potential of the Ca II 8542A line for solar filaments
• Spectro-imagery of an active tornado-like prominence: formation and evolution
• Two Solar Tornadoes Observed with the Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph
• On the magnetism and dynamics of prominence legs hosting tornadoes
• Comparing UV/EUV line parameters and magnetic field in a quiescent prominence with tornadoes
• Rapid Rotation of an Erupting Prominence and the Associated Coronal Mass Ejection on 13 May 2013
• Large-Scale Vortex Motion and Multiple Plasmoid Ejection Due to Twisting Prominence Threads and Associated Reconnection
• Exploration of long-period oscillations in an H$\alpha$ prominence
• Seven decades of exploring planetary interiors with rotating convection experiments
• A spectroscopic investigation of thermal instability for cylindrical equilibria with background flow
• Self-Similar Approach for Rotating Magnetohydrodynamic Solar and Astrophysical Structures
• A persistent quiet-Sun small-scale tornado. II. Oscillations
• Magnetic thread twisting in a simulated solar atmosphere