Slow-down or speed-up of inter- and intra-cluster diffusion of controversial knowledge in stubborn communities based on a small world network
arXiv:1506.08378 · doi:10.3389/fphy.2015.00043
Abstract
Diffusion of knowledge is expected to be huge when agents are open minded. The report concerns a more difficult diffusion case when communities are made of stubborn agents. Communities having markedly different opinions are for example the Neocreationist and Intelligent Design Proponents (IDP), on one hand, and the Darwinian Evolution Defenders (DED), on the other hand. The case of knowledge diffusion within such communities is studied here on a network based on an adjacency matrix built from time ordered selected quotations of agents, whence for inter- and intra-communities. The network is intrinsically directed and not necessarily reciprocal. Thus, the adjacency matrices have complex eigenvalues, the eigenvectors present complex components. A quantification of the slow-down or speed-up effects of information diffusion in such temporal networks, with non-Markovian contact sequences, can be made by comparing the real time dependent (directed) network to its counterpart, the time aggregated (undirected) network, - which has real eigenvalues. In order to do so, small world networks which both contain an number of nodes are studied and compared to similar networks with an number of nodes. It is found that (i) the diffusion of knowledge is more difficult on the largest networks, (ii) the network size influences the slowing-down or speeding-up diffusion process. Interestingly, it is observed that (iii) the diffusion of knowledge is slower in IDP and faster in DED communities. It is suggested that the finding can be "rationalized", if some "scientific quality" and "publication habit" is attributed to the agents, as common sense would guess. This finding offers some opening discussion toward tying scientific knowledge to belief.
arXiv comment16 pages, 28 references, 6 Tables, prepared for a Frontiers Research Topic "Opinions, Choices and Actions: Applications of Sociophysics to the diffusion of ideas" issue, A. Martins & S.Galam, Eds
References in corpus (9)
- Opinion evolution in closed community
- Analyzing and Modeling Real-World Phenomena with Complex Networks: A Survey of Applications
- Causality-Driven Slow-Down and Speed-Up of Diffusion in Non-Markovian Temporal Networks
- The role of inflexible minorities in the breaking of democratic opinion dynamics
- The building up of individual inflexibility in opinion dynamics
- Coexistence of opposite opinions in a network with communities
- Public debates driven by incomplete scientific data: the cases of evolution theory, global warming and H1N1 pandemic influenza
- Complex-valued information entropy measure for networks with directed links (digraphs). Application to citations by community agents with opposite opinions
- Organization of networks with tagged nodes and biased links: a priori distinct communities. The case of Intelligent Design Proponents and Darwinian Evolution Defenders