Can weakly nonlinear theory explain Faraday wave patterns near onset?
arXiv:1504.01553 · doi:10.1017/jfm.2015.388
Abstract
The Faraday problem is an important pattern-forming system that provides some middle ground between systems where the initial instability involves just a single mode and in which complexity then results from mode interactions or secondary bifurcations, and cases where a system is highly turbulent and many spatial and temporal modes are excited. It has been a rich source of novel patterns and of theoretical work aimed at understanding how and why such patterns occur. Yet it is particularly challenging to tie theory to experiment: the experiments are difficult to perform; the parameter regime of interest (large box, moderate viscosity) along with the technical difficulties of solving the free boundary Navier--Stokes equations make numerical solution of the problem hard; and the fact that the instabilities result in an entire circle of unstable wavevectors presents considerable theoretical difficulties. In principle, weakly nonlinear theory should be able to predict which patterns are stable near pattern onset. In this paper we present the first quantitative comparison between weakly nonlinear theory of the full Navier-Stokes equations and (previously published) experimental results for the Faraday problem with multiple frequency forcing. We confirm that three-wave interactions sit at the heart of why complex patterns are stablised but also highlight some discrepancies between theory and experiment. These suggest the need for further experimental and theoretical work to fully investigate the issues of pattern bistability and the role of bicritical/tricritical points in determining bifurcation structure.
arXiv comment30 pages, 15 figures
References in corpus (18)
- Theoretical Model for Faraday Waves with Multiple-Frequency Forcing
- Superlattice Patterns in Surface Waves
- Pattern formation in weakly damped Faraday waves
- Amplitude equations and pattern selection in Faraday waves
- Pattern formation in 2-frequency forced parametric waves
- Numerical simulation of Faraday waves
- Nonlinear Competition Between Small and Large Hexagonal Patterns
- Parametrically Excited Surface Waves: Two-Frequency Forcing, Normal Form Symmetries, and Pattern Selection
- Two-frequency forced Faraday waves: Weakly damped modes and pattern selection
- Multi-frequency control of Faraday wave patterns
- Broken symmetries and pattern formation in two-frequency forced Faraday waves
- Design of parametrically forced patterns and quasipatterns
- Alternating hexagonal and striped patterns in Faraday surface waves
- Three-wave interactions and spatio-temporal chaos
- Convergence properties of the 8, 10 and 12 mode representations of quasipatterns
- Numerical simulation of super-square patterns in Faraday waves
- On the existence of quasipattern solutions of the Swift-Hohenberg equation
- Localized patterns in periodically forced systems
Cited by in corpus (11)
- Soft-core particles freezing to form a quasicrystal and a crystal-liquid phase
- Structural crossover in a model fluid exhibiting two length scales: repercussions for quasicrystal formation
- Which wavenumbers determine the thermodynamic stability of soft matter quasicrystals?
- Spatiotemporal chaos and quasipatterns in coupled reaction-diffusion systems
- Faraday instability on a sphere: numerical simulation
- Quasicrystal formation in binary soft matter mixtures
- Hysteretic Faraday Waves
- Localised patterns in a generalised Swift--Hohenberg equation with a quartic marginal stability curve
- Patterns and quasipatterns from the superposition of two hexagonal lattices
- Design of linear block copolymers and ABC star terpolymers that produce two length scales at phase separation
- The nonlinear stability regime of the viscous Faraday wave problem