The Hubbard Dimer: A density functional case study of a many-body problem

Abstract

This review explains the relationship between density functional theory and strongly correlated models using the simplest possible example, the two-site Hubbard model. The relationship to traditional quantum chemistry is included. Even in this elementary example, where the exact ground-state energy and site occupations can be found analytically, there is much to be explained in terms of the underlying logic and aims of Density Functional Theory. Although the usual solution is analytic, the density functional is given only implicitly. We overcome this difficulty using the Levy-Lieb construction to create a parametrization of the exact function with negligible errors. The symmetric case is most commonly studied, but we find a rich variation in behavior by including asymmetry, as strong correlation physics vies with charge-transfer effects. We explore the behavior of the gap and the many-body Green's function, demonstrating the `failure' of the Kohn-Sham method to reproduce the fundamental gap. We perform benchmark calculations of the occupation and components of the KS potentials, the correlation kinetic energies, and the adiabatic connection. We test several approximate functionals (restricted and unrestricted Hartree-Fock and Bethe Ansatz Local Density Approximation) to show their successes and limitations. We also discuss and illustrate the concept of the derivative discontinuity. Useful appendices include analytic expressions for Density Functional energy components, several limits of the exact functional (weak- and strong-coupling, symmetric and asymmetric), the Kohn-Sham hopping energy functional for 3 sites, various adiabatic connection results, proofs of exact conditions for this model, and the origin of the Hubbard model from a minimal basis model for stretched H${}_2$.

References in corpus (30)

• Localization and delocalization errors in density functional theory and implications for band-gap prediction
• Time-dependent density functional theory: Past, present, and future
• Fractional charge perspective on the band-gap in density-functional theory
• Libxc: a library of exchange and correlation functionals for density functional theory
• Interactions and phase transitions on graphene's honeycomb lattice
• Two Fermions in a double well: Exploring a fundamental building block of the Hubbard model
• The discontinuous nature of the exchange-correlation functional -- critical for strongly correlated systems
• DFT: A Theory Full of Holes?
• Strong correlation in Kohn-Sham density functional theory
• Combining DFT and Many-Body Methods to Understand Correlated Materials
• Beyond the GW approximation: combining correlation channels
• Kohn-Sham calculations with the exact functional
• The Kohn-Sham system in one-matrix functional theory
• Density-functional theory of two-component Bose gases in one-dimensional harmonic traps
• Emergence of Wigner molecules in one-dimensional systems of repulsive fermions under harmonic confinement
• Collective excitations in one-dimensional ultracold Fermi gases: a comparative study
• Adiabatic Connection for Strictly-Correlated Electrons
• Successes and failures of Bethe Ansatz Density Functional Theory
• Interacting fermions in 1D disordered lattices: Exploring localization and transport properties with lattice density-functional theories
• DFT-based many-body analysis of electron transport through molecules
• 2kF-Friedel to 4kF-Wigner oscillations in one-dimensional Fermi gases under confinement
• Spin-independent v-representability of Wigner crystal oscillations in one-dimensional Hubbard chains: The role of spin-charge separation
• Friedel oscillations in one-dimensional metals: from Luttinger's theorem to the Luttinger liquid
• Interacting Fermi Gases in Disordered One-Dimensional Lattices
• Density functional theory for a model quantum dot: Beyond the local-density approximation
• Solving lattice density functionals close to the Mott regime
• Density-functional formulations for quantum chains
• Effects of disorder on atomic density waves and spin-singlet dimers in one-dimensional optical lattices
• Levy-Lieb principle: The bridge between the electron density of Density Functional Theory and the wavefunction of Quantum Monte Carlo
• Competition between local potentials and attractive particle-particle interactions in superlattices

Cited by in corpus (67)

• Quantum embedding methods for correlated excited states of point defects: Case studies and challenges
• Exact ensemble density functional theory for excited states in a model system: investigating the weight dependence of the correlation energy
• Unified formulation of fundamental and optical gap problems in density-functional theory for ensembles
• Diverging exchange force and form of the exact density matrix functional
• Individual correlations in ensemble density-functional theory: State-driven/density-driven decompositions without additional Kohn-Sham systems
• Can ensemble density functional theory yield accurate double excitations?
• Ground and excited energy levels can be extracted exactly from a single ensemble density-functional theory calculation
• Exact conditions on the temperature dependence of density functionals
• Ensemble Density Functional Theory of Neutral and Charged Excitations
• Exact thermal density functional theory for a model system: Correlation components and accuracy of the zero-temperature exchange-correlation approximation
• Non-Adiabatic Approximations in Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory: Progress and Prospects
• Landscape of an exact energy functional
• Relaxation dynamics in a Hubbard dimer coupled to fermionic baths: phenomenological description and its microscopic foundation
• A weight-dependent local correlation density-functional approximation for ensembles
• Singling Out Dynamic and Nondynamic Correlation
• Perturbation Theory in the Complex Plane: Exceptional Points and Where to Find Them
• Random Phase Approximation for gapped systems: role of vertex corrections and applicability of the constrained random phase approximation
• Reduced Density Matrix Functional Theory for Bosons
• Local density approximation in site-occupation embedding theory
• Density functional theory of electron transfer beyond the Born-Oppenheimer approximation: Case study of LiF
• Reduced density-matrix functionals applied to the Hubbard dimer
• Density-functional theory for systems with noncollinear spin: orbital-dependent exchange-correlation functionals and their application to the Hubbard dimer
• N-centered ensemble density-functional theory for open systems
• Refining and relating fundamentals of functional theory
• An efficient method for strongly correlated electrons in one dimension
• An efficient method for strongly correlated electrons in two-dimensions
• Work-distribution quantumness and irreversibility when crossing a quantum phase transition in finite time
• Exact Excited-State Functionals of the Asymmetric Hubbard Dimer
• Householder transformed density matrix functional embedding theory
• Scrutinizing $GW$-based methods using the Hubbard dimer
• Deriving density-matrix functionals for excited states
• Projected site-occupation embedding theory
• Exchange-correlation magnetic fields in spin-density-functional theory
• Exact Maps in Density Functional Theory for Lattice Models
• Quantum many-body states and Green functions of nonequilibrium electron-magnon systems: Localized spin operators vs. their mapping to Holstein-Primakoff bosons
• Seven Useful Questions in Density Functional Theory
• Neutral electronic excitations and derivative discontinuities: An extended $N$-centered ensemble density functional theory perspective
• A Snapshot of Time-Dependent Density-Functional Theory
• Many-body effects on the thermodynamics of closed quantum systems
• Density functionals and Kohn-Sham potentials with minimal wavefunction preparations on a quantum computer
• Relativistic magnetic interactions from non-orthogonal basis sets
• Kinetic-Energy Density-Functional Theory on a Lattice
• Quantifying the effect of interactions in quantum many-body systems
• Melting a Hubbard dimer: benchmarks of `ALDA' for quantum thermodynamics
• Geometrical Perspective on Spin-Lattice Density-Functional Theory
• Extended $N$-centered ensemble density functional theory of double electronic excitations
• Benchmark study of an auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo technique for the Hubbard model with shifted-discrete Hubbard-Stratonovich transformations
• (Spin-)density-functional theory for open-shell systems: exact magnetization density functional for the half-filled Hubbard trimer
• Multiple impurities and combined local density approximations in Site-Occupation Embedding Theory
• Excited-State-Specific Kohn-Sham Formalism for the Asymmetric Hubbard Dimer
• What can lattice DFT teach us about real-space DFT?
• Characterizing Adiabaticity in Quantum Many-Body Systems at Finite Temperature
• Extracting Many-Body Quantum Resources within One-Body Reduced Density Matrix Functional Theory
• Thermal stitching: Extending the reach of quantum fermion solvers
• Can the Hartree-Fock kinetic energy exceed the exact kinetic energy?
• Site-occupation--Green's function embedding theory: A density-functional approach to dynamical impurity solvers
• Dynamical exchange-correlation potential formalism for spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ Heisenberg and Hubbard chains: the antiferromagnetic/half-filled case
• Physics-informed neural networks for solving functional renormalization group on a lattice
• Approximating quantum thermodynamic properties using DFT
• The Levy-Lieb embedding of density functional theory and its Quantum Kernel: Illustration for the Hubbard Dimer using near-term quantum algorithms
• Mean-field approximation of the Hubbard model expressed in a many-body basis
• Degree of simplicity of Floquet states of a periodically driven Bose-Hubbard dimer
• Efficiency of free auxiliary models in describing interacting fermions: from the Kohn-Sham model to the optimal entanglement model
• Ensemble density functional theory of excited states: Exact N-centered formalism and practical opportunities
• Comparing correlation components and approximations in Hartree-Fock and Kohn-Sham theories via an analytical test case study
• Constrained Search in Imaginary Time
• Density-Functional Theory on Graphs