Bayesian decision making in human collectives with binary choices

Abstract

Here we focus on the description of the mechanisms behind the process of information aggregation and decision making, a basic step to understand emergent phenomena in society, such as trends, information spreading or the wisdom of crowds. In many situations, agents choose between discrete options. We analyze experimental data on binary opinion choices in humans. The data consists of two separate experiments in which humans answer questions with a binary response, where one is correct and the other is incorrect. The questions are answered without and with information on the answers of some previous participants. We find that a Bayesian approach captures the probability of choosing one of the answers. The influence of peers is uncorrelated with the difficulty of the question. The data is inconsistent with Weber's law, which states that the probability of choosing an option depends on the proportion of previous answers choosing that option and not on the total number of those answers. Last, the present Bayesian model fits reasonably well to the data as compared to some other previously proposed functions although the latter sometime perform slightly better than the Bayesian model. The asset of the present model is the simplicity and mechanistic explanation of the behavior.

8 pages, 6 figures, 1 table

References in corpus (13)

• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Human strategy updating in evolutionary games
• Social Influence and the Collective Dynamics of Opinion Formation
• Continuous Opinions and Discrete Actions in Opinion Dynamics Problems
• Wisdom of groups promotes cooperation in evolutionary social dilemmas
• Individual rules for trail pattern formation in Argentine ants (Linepithema humile)
• A common rule for decision-making in animal collectives across species
• Collective Animal Behavior from Bayesian Estimation and Probability Matching
• An Opinion Dynamics Model for the Diffusion of Innovations
• The Future of Social Experimenting
• Phase transition to two-peaks phase in an information cascade voting experiment
• A collective opinion formation model under Bayesian updating and confirmation bias
• Collective Adoption of Max-Min Strategy in an Information Cascade Voting Experiment

Cited by in corpus (5)

• A Bayesian Approach to the Naming Game Model
• Detection of phase transition in generalized Pólya urn in information cascade experiment
• Collective decision-making under changing social environments among agents adapted to sparse connectivity
• Collective intelligence: aggregation of information from neighbors in a guessing game
• Bayesian Social Influence in the Online Realm