On the dangers of partial diagrammatic summations: Benchmarks for the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime

Abstract

We study the two-dimensional Hubbard model in the weak-coupling regime and compare the self-energy obtained from various approximate diagrammatic schemes to the result of diagrammatic Monte Carlo simulations, which sum up all weak-coupling diagrams up to a given order. While dynamical mean-field theory provides a good approximation for the local part of the self-energy, including its frequency dependence, the partial summation of bubble and/or ladder diagrams typically yields worse results than second order perturbation theory. Even widely used self-consistent schemes such as GW or the fluctuation-exchange approximation (FLEX) are found to be unreliable. Combining the dynamical mean-field self-energy with the nonlocal component of GW in GW+DMFT yields improved results for the local self-energy and nonlocal self-energies of the correct order of magnitude, but here, too, a more reliable scheme is obtained by restricting the nonlocal contribution to the second order diagram. FLEX+DMFT is found to give accurate results in the low-density regime, but even worse results than FLEX near half-filling.

arXiv commentpublished version with extended discussion; 15 pages, 11 figures

References in corpus (36)

• The density-matrix renormalization group in the age of matrix product states
• The GW method
• Quantum Cluster Theories
• A continuous-time solver for quantum impurity models
• The ALPS project release 1.3: open source software for strongly correlated systems
• The ALPS project release 2.0: Open source software for strongly correlated systems
• Dynamical vertex approximation - a step beyond dynamical mean field theory
• First principles approach to the electronic structure of strongly correlated systems: combining GW and DMFT
• Extended Dynamical Mean Field Theory and GW method
• Kosterlitz-Thouless Transition and Short Range Spatial Correlations in an Extended Hubbard Model
• Satellites and large doping- and temperature-dependence of electronic properties in hole-doped BaFe2As2
• Efficient DMFT-simulation of the Holstein-Hubbard Model
• The f-electron challenge: localized and itinerant states in lanthanide oxides united by GW@LDA+U
• Non Fermi Liquid Behaviour near a $T=0$ spin-glass transition
• Screening and Non-local Correlations in the Extended Hubbard Model from Self-Consistent Combined GW and Dynamical Mean Field Theory
• Pseudogap effects induced by resonant pair scattering
• Diagrammatic Monte Carlo
• Non-existence of the Luttinger-Ward functional and misleading convergence of skeleton diagrammatic series for Hubbard-like models
• Bold Diagrammatic Monte Carlo: When Sign Problem is Welcome
• Diagrammatic Monte Carlo for Correlated Fermions
• From infinite to two dimensions through the functional renormalization group
• Long-range Coulomb interactions in surface systems: a first principles description within self-consistently combined GW and dynamical mean field theory
• Thermodynamics of the 3D Hubbard model on approach to the Neel transition
• Dynamical Screening in Correlated Electron Materials
• Momentum-sector-selective metal-insulator transition in the eight-site dynamical mean-field approximation to the Hubbard model in two dimensions
• Spectral Properties of Correlated Materials: Local Vertex and Non-Local Two-Particle Correlations from Combined GW and Dynamical Mean Field Theory
• Two-stage metal-insulator transition in the 2D Hubbard model: momentum selectivity in the 8-site dynamical cluster approximation
• Extended dynamical mean-field study of the Hubbard model with long range interactions
• One-particle irreducible functional approach - a new route to diagrammatic extensions of DMFT
• Nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory based on weak-coupling perturbation expansions: Application to dynamical symmetry breaking in the Hubbard model
• High-Tc Superconductivity near the Anion Height Instability in Fe-based Superconductors: Analysis of LaFeAsO${}_{1-x}$H${}_x$
• Equation of State of the Fermionic 2D Hubbard Model
• Dynamical screening in La2CuO4
• Spectra and total energies from self-consistent many-body perturbation theory
• Orbital mixture effect on the Fermi surface-$T_c$ correlation in the cuprate superconductors --- bilayer vs single layer
• Assessment of the GW approximation using Hubbard chains

Cited by in corpus (58)

• Diagrammatic routes to nonlocal correlations beyond dynamical mean field theory
• Mott physics and spin fluctuations: a functional viewpoint
• Quantum Monte-Carlo for correlated out-of-equilibrium nanoelectronics devices
• Finite temperature quantum embedding theories for correlated systems
• Consistent partial bosonization of the extended Hubbard model
• Charge ordering and correlation effects in the extended Hubbard model
• Nonperturbative Quantum Physics from Low-Order Perturbation Theory
• Dynamical screening in correlated electron systems - from lattice models to realistic materials
• FLEX+DMFT approach to the $d$-wave superconducting phase diagram of the two-dimensional Hubbard model
• Diagrammatic Monte Carlo approach for diagrammatic extensions of dynamical mean-field theory -- convergence analysis of the dual fermion technique
• On the limitations of cRPA downfolding
• Connections and performances of Green's function methods for charged and neutral excitations
• Rigorous ab initio quantum embedding for quantum chemistry using Green's function theory: screened interaction, non-local self-energy relaxation, orbital basis, and chemical accuracy
• Diagrammatic Monte Carlo for Dual Fermions
• Impact of partially bosonized collective fluctuations on electronic degrees of freedom
• Determinant Monte Carlo algorithms for dynamical quantities in fermionic systems
• From local to non-local correlations: the Dual Boson perspective
• Dual Boson Diagrammatic Monte Carlo Approach Applied to the Extended Hubbard Model
• Renormalized Singles Green's Function in the T-Matrix Approximation for Accurate Quasiparticle Energy Calculation
• Pairing and non-Fermi liquid behavior in partially flat-band systems
• Reference Energies for Valence Ionizations and Satellite Transitions
• Optimal grouping of arbitrary diagrammatic expansions via analytic pole structure
• A similarity renormalization group approach to Green's function methods
• Algorithmic approach to diagrammatic expansions for real-frequency evaluation of susceptibility functions
• Hypergeometric resummation of self-consistent sunset diagrams for electron-boson quantum many-body systems out of equilibrium
• Static and Dynamic Bethe-Salpeter Equations in the $T$-Matrix Approximation
• Rigorous screened interactions for realistic correlated electron systems
• The (extended) dynamical mean field theory combined with the two-particle irreducible functional renormalization-group approach as a tool to study strongly-correlated systems
• Interplay of Pomeranchuk instability and superconductivity in the two-dimensional repulsive Hubbard model
• Collective magnetic fluctuations in Hubbard plaquettes captured by fluctuating local field method
• Auxiliary Field Quantum Monte Carlo for Multiband Hubbard Models: Controlling the Sign and Phase Problems to Capture Hund's Physics
• Magnon-driven chiral charge and spin pumping and electron-magnon scattering from time-dependent quantum transport combined with atomistic spin dynamics theory
• Strongly correlated superconductivity with long-range spatial fluctuations
• Nonequilibrium Two-Particle Self-Consistent Approach
• Local and nonlocal electronic correlations at the metal-insulator transition in the Hubbard model in two dimensions
• Phase transitions in partial summation methods: Results from the 3D Hubbard model
• Beyond quasi-particle self-consistent $GW$ for molecules with vertex corrections
• Quantum many-body states and Green functions of nonequilibrium electron-magnon systems: Localized spin operators vs. their mapping to Holstein-Primakoff bosons
• Pseudoparticle vertex solver for quantum impurity models
• Nonlocal corrections to dynamical mean-field theory from the two-particle self-consistent method
• Anomalous propagators and the particle-particle channel: Hedin's equations
• An Improved Two-Particle Self-Consistent Approach
• Single particle properties of the 2D Hubbard model for real frequencies at weak coupling: Breakdown of the Dyson series for partial self-energy expansions
• Local Self-Energies for V and Pd Emergent from a Non-Local LDA+FLEX Implementation
• Stochastic pole expansion method
• Dynamical Mean Field Theory extension to the nonequilibrium Two-Particle Self-Consistent approach
• Non-local Correlation Effects in Fermionic Many-Body Systems: Overcoming the Non-causality Problem
• DFT+DMFT with natural atomic orbital projectors
• Towards numerically exact computation of conductivity in the thermodynamic limit of interacting lattice models
• Real-frequency TPSC+DMFT investigation of the square-lattice Hubbard model
• Barycentric rational function approximation made simple: A fast analytic continuation method for Matsubara Green's functions
• Spin correlations in the bilayer Hubbard model with perpendicular electric field
• The hierarchical Green function approach to the two-dimensional Hubbard model
• Combinatorial summation of Feynman diagrams: Equation of state of the 2D SU(N) Hubbard model
• The analytical description of a doped Mott insulator
• Momentum-dependent relaxation dynamics of the doped repulsive Hubbard model
• Median-point approximation and its application for the study of fermionic systems
• Self-consistent $GW$+Extended Dynamical Mean Field Theory for semiconductors and insulators